Be honest Pennington > or = to Jay Fiedler? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Be honest Pennington > or = to Jay Fiedler?

Who do you prefer be honest?

  • Pennington

    Votes: 226 94.2%

  • Fiedler

    Votes: 14 5.8%
  • Total voters
    240
finfan75

finfan75

Starter
Joined
Dec 17, 2004
Messages
696
Reaction score
1
Location
Southaven
Fiedler got us to the Playoffs a couple years straight and just faltered. I hope this is not what is going to happen these next couple of years. I have faith. Any experts want to chime in?

Do you see differences or similarities in the two?
 
anyone who thinks Fielder was better needs to get an eye exam and a catscan lol.
 
No expert, but Pennington is definitly better than Fiedler. Not hateing on Jay, but, Jay had light years more talent on the team and, still couldn't get it done.
 
Pennington by a mile.

Chad needs more weapons at WR and he'll remain a Top 10 QB in the league.
 
16 now.lol easy*

fiedler with this same talent compared to the one fiedler had would of won 6 games at best.
 
A Ferrari or a Honda? Adriana Lima or Rosie Odonell? Filet Mignon or Dog Food?? Sorry but you have to blind retarded and high to pick fiedler
 
Pennington is a decent to good starter while Fiedler was a semi-reliable backup who was given a starting job.
 
I'd have to say:
Arm:pennington=Fiedler
Decision Making:pennington>Fiedler
Mobility:pennington<Fiedler
Pocket Presence: Pennington>Fiedler
Reading the Defense: Pennington>Fiedler
Leadership: Pennington>Fiedler
Overall: Pennington>Fiedler
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom