Ben Volin: Dolphins in negotiations with Alex Smith | Page 3 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Ben Volin: Dolphins in negotiations with Alex Smith

PJack said:
You don't really believe he was the main reason for SF's season last year do you? He's a fit for any team with a top 1 or 2 defense as a game manager. SF got there because of a great defense and Smith not taking ANY chances with the ball. That will not work for us IMO. I'd rather still with Moore that give him 9mm a season.
Click to expand...

Smith took NO chances because his options were V. Davis and no one else. You've obviously never played the game. Be a FAN, not a critic. ;-)
 
I could never see Flynn as our starting QB. Too small, no experience, weak arm, 7th round pick...too many questions that 2 wins with GB just didn't answer. I think the FO is handling this very important decision with as much care as it deserves. I'm relieved that we didn't annoint Matt Flynn today. I know its been tumultuous, but we will just have to wait and see. If we can get Smith at about the same amt. that Seattle paid Flynn I think we're the winners in the comparison.
 
jlfin said:
Its funny how the Smith haters won't give the guy ANY credit for leading his team to a 13-3 record. It was all Harbaugh and the defense, Smith contributed nothing. He just went along for the ride.
The guy is mentally tough and has had no opportunity to develop his game until last yr,. How many coaching changes/OC's has he endured the last 6 yrs?
Click to expand...

I agree, people will say that it doesn't matter how good Miami's Defence is that until we get a QB we wont be in the playoffs, yet they say that SF's D did it all nothing to do with Smith. If Smith is as big of a piece of garbage as you say then it wouldn't have mattered how good the 49ers D was either.

I didn't want Flynn so not too upset, Tannehill is still the guy I want most so we will see how that works out.
 
andyahs said:
I would take him over Flynn.
Click to expand...

He was good enough to help the 49ers get to the championship game because of good coaching. I think we have good coachiong and he could do good for us, so yes I too would take him. Obviously Philbin knows something or they would have battled harder for Flynn. If he feels Smith can do the same as Flynn why not consider him? Has a lot more experience, too.
 
at least we will finally have a quarterback that was drafted with the first pick of a nfl draft. lol
 
i dont care if they sign my nine year old son, just get a qb so i can move on from this crap
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom