Best and most realistic return for the 3rd overall pick? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Best and most realistic return for the 3rd overall pick?

Who bites? Someone who needs a QB. Would anyone trade up for Sewell?
 
allsilverdreams said:
I'm hoping for a first and 2 nd in this year as well as next year's draft. Can we actually receive this without dropping past 10?
I'm thinking Atlanta may come calling.
Click to expand...
Unfortunately, I think this is not only a bad year for tradedown value in general, but we aren't really in a position of leverage to begin with. Teams are aware of our obvious preference to trade down, so unless there are multiple competing offers (a bidding war) we have to take what we can get, or stay put.

A lot depends on what the jests do at #2. If they take fields, I think we are $hit outta luck. If they go a different direction, we might get a very nice return, as I think there would be more than one team in the market.

Gut feeling, we aren't getting 2 #1s and 2 #2s and still stay in the top 10.
 
Well we know Detroit isn't trading up for a QB. Also, I don't see Chicago, Carolina or San Fran trading up either, it seems those teams are looking for experienced QB's.
 
Completely depends on the market... Has as much to do with what Grier + Flo are willing to take to move down -- and of course if ? they have a player they want enough to NOT move.

My take is the value in a pick @3 is QB only -- and specifically Wilson. More and more predictions the Jets grab him so I'm definitely trending towards trade. In that situation you have to hope a team is horny as hell for Fields and we can score big.

Taking Smith at 3 would be foolish IMO and to be avoided at all costs -- I'd take Chase before the stick man. Not sold on Sewell that high for us -- or Parsons. Have to hope a team is willing to move and I assume Grier accepting a deal that's less than the bonanza we'd hope for.
 
I think the best trade partners are Carolina, Denver and San Francisco. I'm not sure it makes sense for Atlanta. Philadelphia might be a dark horse.

With SF, I'd want at the very least Ayuk, a 2021 #1 and a 2022 #1.

Carolina and Denver would need something along the lines of 2021 #1, 2021 #2 and 2022 #1.
 
If it's a trade with Atlanta to move down one spot, we might get their 2nd round pick.

If we are moving down to #12 (Frisco), then I think we could expect to get their 2nd this year and their first next year.

Obviously, I'd ask for more.
 
The ultimate fantasy draft trade is the Eagles Wentz deal. A top 10 pick, first rounder in 2022, and a few mid round picks. The obvious candidate being the Panthers, sitting at 8 with a need for a franchise cornerstone.

The other fantasy would be the Ricky trade, fleecing some team further down in the teens desperate for a player they think will put them over the top. I'm not sure that player exists in this draft unless someone thinks Ja'Marr Chase is the second coming of Rice or something.

The more likely option available would be moving down a few spots and picking up a second rounder. The Bengals if they're desperate for Sewell could be looking to move up.

The reality is none of us have a clue what front offices are thinking. All it takes is one nutty GM or impatient owner thinking Zach Wilson or Trey Lance is the next Mahomes. The Phins just have to hope that GM is out there and things fall in place for them on draft day.
 
BigNastyFish said:
Completely depends on the market... Has as much to do with what Grier + Flo are willing to take to move down -- and of course if ? they have a player they want enough to NOT move.

My take is the value in a pick @3 is QB only -- and specifically Wilson. More and more predictions the Jets grab him so I'm definitely trending towards trade. In that situation you have to hope a team is horny as hell for Fields and we can score big.

Taking Smith at 3 would be foolish IMO and to be avoided at all costs -- I'd take Chase before the stick man. Not sold on Sewell that high for us -- or Parsons. Have to hope a team is willing to move and I assume Grier accepting a deal that's less than the bonanza we'd hope for.
Click to expand...
Uunfortunately your last sentence is probably what it ultimately boils down to, unless we are willing to drop a lot lower than I would like.
 
The trade value chart I’m looking at has our pick at #3 worth 2200 points.

Detroit at #7 is worth 1500.
Carolina at #8 is worth 1400.
Denver at #9 is worth 1350.

For comparison Detroit #2 (41) is 490.
Carolina #2 (39) is 510.
Denver #2 (40) is 500.

So we’re looking at minimum at a #2 and a #3 according to the chart to get close to even value. But if I’m Miami I’m asking for that 2022 #1 to start with.

Would you rather get a 2nd and 3rd this draft or would you rather just get a 2022 #1?
 
I feel like the only way we can have the falcons trade with us is if they are afraid some other team will instead for a qb
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom