I think that list is pretty accurate. Had Miami retained Troy Vincent, he would be #1 on my list. As it is, I would put Patrick Surtain first, followed by Sam Madison, Troy Vincent and Don McNeal. McNeal was a really good player, but unfortunately he is probably most known for missing a tackle (sliding off) Jon Riggins in the super bowl. The Dolphins haven't honestly had too many great corners. In the 70's, they had a pair of great safeties in Dick Anderson and Jake Scott both of whom should be in the hall of fame IMO. Anderson had probably the best defensive game I have ever seen by a Dolphin player against Pittsburgh coming up with four interceptions in a Monday night 30-26 win. Those are two players I wish you could have seen and were a big part of Miami's defense during those great years.