Best move is to trade down | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Best move is to trade down

phinfreak

☠️ Banned ☠️
Joined
Oct 14, 2005
Messages
963
Reaction score
22
Best value in bottom half of 1st and top half of second rounds.

With all the holes fins need to fill, the best value for our money would be to load up on picks.

Fins have equal pressing needs at NT, ILB, S, OLB, TE, WR, G

Just too many holes to fill with good depth in this years draft.

I expect fins to package #12 + players for additional 2nd or 3rd round picks.
 
I agree 100%. It would be tempting if McClain and or Bryant are there at #12, but like you said there is a lot of value from mid round 1 through the third round. I think Miami will try and get as many picks in those rounds as possible and trading back is probably the easiest way to do it.
 
trading down is the best move in any year, in any round, for any team ...

it's not really up for debate
 
So if best value is in the middle of the 1st, then why would any of those teams want to trade up?
 
Trade down 100 percent..You get more pics as in Angerer or Tebow..Guys you wouldn't think we were gonna take..Trade Pat White for another pick..
 
So if best value is in the middle of the 1st, then why would any of those teams want to trade up?

Teams feel a player fits a certain need or they fall in love with a player.
 
I would add that not only would I trade down, but I would do it in exchange for a pick in 2011.
 
It's easier at #12 than it is in the top 10 and there is a good chance a player someone wants is sitting there.

Obviously...

But its hard to get good value for draft picks. Think about it. We are trying to move down. Why. Its a deep draft. Not a real good year to move up.
 
In addition to a 2010 pick? What do you see in 2011 that looks better than this year?


teams always give a better pick in the future than they would give in the present draft year...


much like in finance, people don't understand the concept of making money with money : 100$ now could be worth 110 $ next year ... now, are you the guy who'll lend the "money", or borrow it ?


i guess what ck is trying to say, much like i am, is that a very few select teams understand that concept ... the patriots have been doing it for a long time, and now even McDaniels learned from his mentor and did the same thing in denver... it's about time we start doing the same thing here...
 
In addition to a 2010 pick? What do you see in 2011 that looks better than this year?

First off, I've been talking about this for a while but the senior class this year is pretty poor IMO. The junior class didn't really save it that much. They only tied the record for most early declarations, they didn't shatter it like most predicted would happen because of the looming rookie wage scale in 2011. I know it's cliche to complain about the present draft and say it's not very talented, I hear it every year. Most times I argue against the notion. This year, I believe it's true.

However, when I look at the players set to be available a year from now, as well as the players that could/should declare by then, I'm drooling. I've never had such a clear idea in my head just how good the next class should be. I've certainly never come across a year where I can say with all honesty that so many of the best-in-college at their respective positions, aren't even draft eligible. Jonathan Baldwin is the best WR in college football, rivaled by Julio Jones, Michael Floyd and A.J. Green. None are draft eligible. Andrew Luck is the best QB in college football. He's not draft eligible. Mark Ingram is the best RB in college football. He's not draft eligible. Marcel Dareus and DaQuan Bowers might well be fighting for the right to call themselves the best Defensive Ends in college football, not draft eligible. I think that Patrick Peterson is the best corner in college football, and he's not draft eligible either. You just don't run into a situation like that very often, the best players at their positions not just being underclassmen but being draft ineligible. Is Derrick Morgan better than Dareus or Bowers? I don't know, I don't think so. Is Spiller better than Ingram? I'm not sure. Is Dez Bryant better than Baldwin? I don't think so. Is Clausen better than Luck? Not if you ask me. Is Haden better than Peterson? Not in my opinion. With as talented as those guys I would expect the bulk of them to come out early next year...because they don't have as much to prove.

And that's even taking aside the guys that decided to stay in school, and should be seniors next year. Jake Locker, Christian Ponder and Ryan Mallett round out a very solid upper QB class next year even if Andrew Luck doesn't come out (and I think he will, because by the end of next year I'm willing to bet Harbaugh leaves the program for greener pastures). Gabe Carimi and Nate Solder are very solid OTs that stayed in school. I think the world of Orlando Franklin as a Guard prospect, and both Rodney Hudson and Mike Pouncey also stayed in school at that position. Cameron Heyward and Greg Romeus stayed in school, as did Adrian Clayborn. Heyward and Clayborn in particular could be very high draft prospects. Marvin Austin and Allen Bailey stayed in school, as did Stephen Paea. Bruce Carter, Von Miller and none other than Mark Herzlich should round out a heck of a linebacker upper class, the sort that make you drool. Ras-I Dowling stayed in school and I think he has a lot of potential as a corner. Charles Brown and Kendric Burner also stayed in school at that spot. DeAndre McDaniel is a very promising safety prospect.

I mean, that's about 30 names right there...all guys I love, all guys I'd HEAVILY consider for a first round grade in THIS year's draft...all guys that should be in the draft next year.

Should be a banner year. Of course, watch the NFL screw it all up and have a lockout or some crap.
 
Back
Top Bottom