Better QB: Daunte Culpepper or Chad Pennington?

[NYJets ATTACK]

I posted this a few years ago on a Dolphins forum and I got one set of results. It was pretty convincing. I want to see the results now.

Poll coming.

 

[smokin ricky]

right now or career? lol

 

[yellowv]

I think the results are probably different now. LOL

 

[NYJets ATTACK]

I think the results are probably different now. LOL

My answer hasn't changed, was always the same. Never liked ****pepper, he doesn't have "it."

 

[Blackcreekbandit]

really dude? dude who did absolutly nothing for our team but cost us money or a leader turning this whole franchise around you pick

 

[dolpns13]

Im not even going to answer... Dumbte is a joke

 

[NYJets ATTACK]

really dude? dude who did absolutly nothing for our team but cost us money or a leader turning this whole franchise around you pick

A lot of people said Daunte Culpepper had a bigger arm, better playmaking potential, and better mobility. The same people said this "comparison" wasn't even close. I'm just curious to see if that's changed.

 

[DZimmer000]

Hey NYJets ATTACK....How's 3rd place? Just curius how you would feel.

 

[NYJets ATTACK]

Let me just say, results are MUCH different this time.

 

[Pennington's Rocket Arm]

A lot of people said Daunte Culpepper had a bigger arm, better playmaking potential, and better mobility. The same people said this "comparison" wasn't even close. I'm just curious to see if that's changed.

of course it's changed, what do you think? what's the point of this...

 

[Dolpfan_72]

LOLpepper is/was/always will be nothing without Moss.

 

[NBP81]

Wich team is better, the Fins or the jests? my anwser has always been the same... BTW good luck in the playoffs... oh I forgot, your not going.

 

[NYJets ATTACK]

Sorry, but it always irritated me that a guy like ****pepper was seen in the same light as a Chad Pennington. I'm just glad that the record has been set straight.

 

[myke1072]

My vote went to the guy that Jets fans booed last year when he got injured.

 

[canesandbhoys]

A lot of people said Daunte Culpepper had a bigger arm, better playmaking potential, and better mobility. The same people said this "comparison" wasn't even close. I'm just curious to see if that's changed.

Taken literally, these things are true. Daunte can throw farther and harder, has more POTENTIAL to be a playmaker, and may still be a better runner from the QB position. However, anyone would take Penny over Culpepper (especially now) because of his intelligence and accuracy. His style of play gives your offense much more stability and a better chance for success every week.