Bigger Defensive Need: LB or DE? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Bigger Defensive Need: LB or DE?

Fin Fan in Cali

Fins Up!
Super Donator
Club Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2004
Messages
58,192
Reaction score
89,211
Age
60
Location
Sunshine state
http://www.thephinsider.com/2017/2/...-free-agency-draft-nfl-2017-prospects-combine

630168632.0.jpg

[h=2]The Case for LB[/h] Aside from Kiko Alonso, no one made plays. Jelani Jenkins is oft-injured, as is Koa Misi (and Misi can be released with nearly $4 million in cap savings). Donald Butler was signed off the street early in 2016 and is now a free agent. Spencer Paysinger is a special teams player with spot duty capability, but a free agent nonetheless.
Mike Hull is an exclusive-rights FA and it’s a no risk move to re-sign him - a great special teams contributor with upside. Neville Hewitt is under contract and had the opportunity to take over a starting position as he replaced Jenkins during his injury - he was lukewarm with this opportunity, and didn’t do enough to separate himself.
It’s expected that Kiko Alonso receives a contract tender (as well as Mike Hull), which leaves the Miami Dolphins with 2 players under contract (Misi, Hewitt), and 2 likely to come back (Hull, Alonso). That’s it. This is not only a concern of talent, but one of bodies.
I was in attendance firsthand watching the Baltimore Ravens dissect the Dolphins LB corps with short passes. Baltimore TE’s accounted for 114 yards and 2 TD’s on that day, and, we probably feel like we’re taking crazy pills by saying this again: it’s difficult for Dolphins LB’s to cover TE’s. San Francisco repeatedly fooled Dolphins LB’s with misdirections and short passes.
Kiko Alonso is the lone piece to build around. The luxury of Alonso is his versatility, manning the MLB spot in 2016, but (arguably) has the capability of moving outside to WLB. An investment in MLB might improve 2 positions in the LB unit.
Koa Misi was the last LB prospect the Miami Dolphins selected in the first 2 rounds (and he played a hybrid DE/LB position at Utah), and that was 2010. It’s been awhile since we’ve invested in the position and it shows.
[h=2]The Case for DE[/h] I mentioned bodies at LB, the DE has two players under contract that had snaps for the Miami Dolphins in 2016: Cameron Wake and Terrence Fede. Terrence Fede’s roughing the punter penalty vs. Cincinnati earned this look from Darren Rizzi (thank you Fuhbawl):
images.jpeg
Dion Jordan is an enigmatic turd wrapped in a burnt-hair diaper of riddles, so it’s anyone’s guess what happens to him - for a DE, he could very well be worth $3.2 million, but then again, he could show up to training camp with a beer-dispensing helmet on and get cut immediately. Andre Branch is a free agent.
Aside from QB, there is arguably no more important a position than defensive end, and the Miami Dolphins not only lack numbers, but they have no heir apparent to Cameron Wake. Even if Andre Branch comes back, there is a legitimate argument the Dolphins need to invest in 2 defensive ends to bolster the pass rush and establish long-term continuity at the position.
If we are to take down the AFC East crown before Tom Brady is 63, the only proven method to disrupt the Patriots offense is to wreak havoc with the front 4, and we simply don’t have the personnel at DE to do that at the current juncture. Our front 7 was anemic against the run, and the defensive ends are not immune from that. The Miami Dolphins, despite splash plays like strip-sacks by Cameron Wake, were bottom half of the league in sacks and fumbles recovered.
We relied on the front 4 all year long, and they simply looked gassed towards the end of the year and into the Playoffs. An influx of young talent and a better rotation at DE is paramount to our immediate and long-term future.
What do you think Dolphins fans: LB or DE? I know it’s hard to choose just one, but would love to hear your thoughts in the Comments Section!
 
Agreed, after Thomas, we have been chasing to fill our glaring hole at LB. Porter, Dansby, etc have been placeholders but no one has been a long term fix. We have to solidify it. It makes me wonder if we have trouble identifying talent or if we have a problem developing talent. Unfortunately, it feels like a little bit of both.
 
I mean you're splitting hairs at this point. But I'm actually not trying to break the bank at either position. So that means pass on JPP, Melvin Ingram, Chandler Jones, and Hightower. Really the only guy in free agency that I'd be willing to spend $13M+/year on is the corner AJ Bouye, because at least with him we could somewhat offset his big deal by cutting Byron Maxwell.

I'm looking at good value signings like Jabaal Sheard (Florida kid) and Zach Brown. The guys I'm willing to spend a little more on are down in the trenches, Zietler, Warford, Leary, Brandon Williams...all with the exception of Zietler could be had for less than $10M/year.
 
Two needs - one doesn't prioritize over the other - you take the better talent available
 
Funny thing is between LB & DE sometimes they are the same thing… Edge, OLB
 
LB...theres 3 of them in our D with arguably only 1 solid starter in Kiko that we have currently...where as we have 1 ProBowl DE and a decent starter at the other spot (albeit free agent) with decent depth behind him...so even if we lost Branch we still have 1 quality starter in wake vs 1 quality starter in Kiko....im hoping maybe mike hull can make his way into the starting lineup have kiko at will and draft foster or cunningham for mike....who knows
 
Lb for sure. Our run defense was horrible and that was the main reason. Also the reason we have such a hard time controlling the clock.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Porque no los dos? They're the two top priorities both equally important. We have an OOP Kiko with garbage around him. Then we have a 35 year old Cam Wake who realistically has a couple years left (typing this made me sad) and we need to groom his replacement preferably in this draft imo. Haason Reddick is a guy I'm hoping we pull the trigger on day two.
 
Linebacker may be the bigger need for the Dolphins but a defensive end is more of a premium position. I would rather have a great defensive end over a great linebacker, but Miami's need is great at both positions, so whoever they rate higher at those positions I would be fine with.
 
It really is very close, and no need to split hairs. I think LB is slightly bigger due to needing two starters, and no option to resign. Guy from last year and be ok. If we keep Branch we are fine at starting DE. We desperately need depth and future at DE. LB we need started, future, and depth, and it was by far our worst position last year.

That being said I think DE gets priority in round 1 of the draft due to how DE is more sought and good ones rarely get out of round 1. LB is always deeper and stars at LB quite often come out of roundss 2-5.
 
Back
Top Bottom