Bills=Worst in draft?????? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Bills=Worst in draft??????

no way. They picked two really good DB's. I don't see what everyone's problem is. Whitner may have been taken early, but he's the player they wanted, he's a stud.
 
Well they reached, but the players they picked are still pretty decent. They just could have probably gotten a lot more value if they could have worked some trades, particularly for the 8th pick. They still have a hatful of needs they've completely missed out on helping though.
 
Rocky Raccoon said:
no way. They picked two really good DB's. I don't see what everyone's problem is. Whitner may have been taken early, but he's the player they wanted, he's a stud.
Click to expand...

uh, 1st rounder McCargo was a reach by several rounds.
 
The Bills win worst in show.

Whitner is a damn good player but a reach and they could have had him AND extra picks AND saved money by moving back.
 
They got 2 studs in the secondary. I don't necessarily agree with McCargo, but I really wanted Donte Whitner in aqua and orange next year.
 
Not really. I heard the Giants were looking at McCargo in the late 1st round and other teams were looking at him early in the 2nd. It was a reach at that point, but i don't think by several rounds. I love Whitner, but they could have traded down if someone wanted to trade up, and still gotten him before Baltimore and Miami.

I think the worst draft so far is Kansas City or the Giants. KC needed DB help and took Hali in the 1st instead of a Joseph, Williams or Kelly Jennings. Then, in the 2nd, they pass on Tim Jennings and Marshall and take Pollard? Ugh. That's why their defense always stinks.

The Giant on the other hand took a guy in round 1 that they can't even play b/c they already have 2 great DEs. Then, the Giants go and trade up for Moss, who they could have taken in round 1. Doesn't make sense.
 
Youboty in the 3rd was a good value pick but so far they've been terrible. They trade up and reach for McCargo and fail to trade down at 8. Unless they thought that Detroit was gonna take Donte Whitner they should've traded down.
 
Well one negative for us is I like what New England has done. They now have a young RB and WR to join Deion Branch (young), Ben Watson (Young and Daniel Graham (Young) and of course Brady. Looks like the Pats have built a good offense for awhile.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom