Brees Or Culpepper : Who's Our Man???... | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Brees Or Culpepper : Who's Our Man???...

BLITZKRIEG

BLITZKRIEG

~LACUNA LEGIONS~
Joined
May 21, 2002
Messages
6,910
Reaction score
11
Location
Ft. Lauderdale, FL
Brees Or Culpepper??...

Well it looks very much like one of these two QB's will be in a Phinz uniform once the market opens. Who's your personal choice, and why???...

I myself feel that Brees would be a better option at this stage. He's coming off a very solid season, and his injury is not as serious as Culpeppers. On top of that, Culpepper is looking for a big pay day....

I'm not sure what kind of contract Brees is going to want, but I'd feel more comfortable giving it to him than anyone else. Let's just hope that the Lions don't make some outlandish bid for him, and that Brees himself knows that Miami is a much more attractive destination....

As for Culpepper, if we lose out on Brees, I'll welcome him just the same. He's a proven pro bowl QB, who's got the capability of throwing more than 30 TD's a season. Just because he's experienced a serious injury to his knee, doesn't mean there's anything wrong with his arm or his competitive spirit....

PHINZ RULE!!!
 
ive said it before and ill say it again culpepper flat out sux.
the only talent he has is called randy moss.
he proved this year that he cant play without moss, he had quality WRs and he couldnt win with them, and then u have an aging vetern that has played in almost 2 year come out and pull almost the biggest comeback of the year and just miss the playoffs. if culpepper hadnt gotten hurt the viks would be picking alot higher than they are
 
Dolfan81 said:
ive said it before and ill say it again culpepper flat out sux.
the only talent he has is called randy moss.
he proved this year that he cant play without moss, he had quality WRs and he couldnt win with them, and then u have an aging vetern that has played in almost 2 year come out and pull almost the biggest comeback of the year and just miss the playoffs. if culpepper hadnt gotten hurt the viks would be picking alot higher than they are
Click to expand...

Please research what you are talking about before you post, ok?

Culpepper's best season had Randy Moss out for several games and hurt for most of the rest. He was inactive or barely active in half of the games.

Culpepper might not be 3300 yards and 64.4% completion percentage on average without Randy Moss, but saying he sucks is one of the stupidest things I've heard around here in a long time.
 
Disgustipate said:
Please research what you are talking about before you post, ok?

Culpepper's best season had Randy Moss out for several games and hurt for most of the rest. He was inactive or barely active in half of the games.

Culpepper might not be 3300 yards and 64.4% completion percentage on average without Randy Moss, but saying he sucks is one of the stupidest things I've heard around here in a long time.
Click to expand...

what did he do this year that justifies he is even a good qb any more?
culpepper ran himself into the ground with all his scrambling he is just not a good qb anymore
 
The Phins would be in a great position with either one. But i believe Culpepperreturns to the Vikes in 06.
 
Dolfan81 said:
what did he do this year that justifies he is even a good qb any more?
culpepper ran himself into the ground with all his scrambling he is just not a good qb anymore
Click to expand...
'
What did he do this year? What is this "What have you done for me lately" garbage?

Please tell me you've watched Dante Culpepper play or at least went and looked at his states. Even if you're lying to me, I need some reassurance here.
 
Two years ago Culpepper was regarded as the second best quarterback in the league, only contested by Manning. My opinion on him now is the same. He has a cannon, and some wheels. He has played great with and without Moss. Saying the Vikes troubles are Culpepper's fault is stupid. The whole team was in shambles most of the season.
 
Daunte Culpepper would look really sweet in a dolphin uniform but so would Drew Brees so lets get Brees.
 
Culpepper is a turnover machine who really had 1 impressive season for me and that was 2 seasons ago when Linehan was his OC. I think Linehan made Culpepper look a lot better then we think considering the beginning of Culpeppers career he had 2 amazing recievers with Cris Carter and Randy Moss. I think Brees is the better QB will be healthier and cheaper. The only advantage I think Culpepper has over Brees is a stronger arm and that isn't enough for me to take Daunte over Brees.
 
Dolfan81 said:
what did he do this year that justifies he is even a good qb any more?
culpepper ran himself into the ground with all his scrambling he is just not a good qb anymore
Click to expand...

He still sucked enough to have a better QB rating and completion percentage than the bum that took snaps for us last year.
 
Disgustipate said:
'
What did he do this year? What is this "What have you done for me lately" garbage?

Please tell me you've watched Dante Culpepper play or at least went and looked at his states. Even if you're lying to me, I need some reassurance here.
Click to expand...

I may have to go with Culpepper now that I hear he has States. How many does he have. Would we have to add some stars to the US flag?
 
i watched him throw 12 interception in 7 games with only 6 tds(gus had 16 in 16 games)
that an avrage of 2 a game(david carr wasnt even that bad)
and i watched him take a playoff team and go 2-4
and i also watched him hurt himself with all his scrambling
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom