Brown/R.Williams or Alstott/C.Williams ? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Brown/R.Williams or Alstott/C.Williams ?

Which backfield is more dangerous ?

  • Ronnie Brown and Ricky Williams

    Votes: 148 93.7%

  • Mike Alstott and Cadillac Williams

    Votes: 4 2.5%

  • About even

    Votes: 6 3.8%
  • Total voters
    158
  • Poll closed .
Alsott is a good short yardage back but he is not dangerous as he can't block well and he has no speed
 
over all, ronnie and ricky b/c we have youth and alstott has lost quite a few step. for longevity it is definitely us.
 
Alstott is nowhere near as complete a player as Brown. And Carnell has a long way to go to accomplish what Ricky has. If I'm a defensive coordinator, I'd much rather face Alstott and Carnell.
 
How could Alstott compare to either Ricky or Ronnie. Alstott is a great FB but there's no comparison in any way.
 
shouright said:
Alstott is nowhere near as complete a player as Brown. And Carnell has a long way to go to accomplish what Ricky has. If I'm a defensive coordinator, I'd much rather face Alstott and Carnell.
Click to expand...

very true
 
BALLS DEEP said:
How could Alstott compare to either Ricky or Ronnie. Alstott is a great FB but there's no comparison in any way.
Click to expand...

I think he was refering to whether or not you would want to game plan against rick/ronnie or alstott/carnell!
 
Alstott can't block. Ricky is a proven commodity, brown has been progressing, Caddillac is good, but injury prone (see college career)
 
Lets see with Ronnie and Ricky you have two bulls, both powerful and speedy. Both can hit a whole hard and if you get either to the line of scrimmage you're gonna get at least 3 or 4 tough yards. Both can block and catch out of the backfield.

With Alstott and Caddy you've got an overused short yardage runner on his last leg with a bad neck and a smooth runner with some power but lack of anything else... HMMM???
 
I think Pittman and Williams is more dangerous than Alstott and Williams.
 
tampa stinks if they didnt play horrible teams they'd be 0-4...sad they say williams is awesome...yea give me the ball versus detroit, buffalo,green bay...2 wins between them..amazing
 
Hmm...Tough call.

Promising rookie and a former rushing title holder

VS

Promising rookie and a has been, fumble prone slow guy that can't block and is a good lick away from being paralized?

Tough call.

Pass?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom