Campbell or Mcpherson

[stoody24]

i personally like mcpherson plus we could get him in the third unlike campbell who would have to be taken in the second, but im open for a debate and my mind can be changed with factual info.

anyone have any combine numbers or workout numbers to compare these two???

 

[tartan y fronts]

mcpherson likely won't be there in the 3rd, so its moot

 

[stoody24]

true but he has a better chance then campbell to make it to the third

 

[touborg]

I'd take any of them over Smith/Rodgers honestly.

 

[PHINATIC13]

6'3"- 227lb. QB from Georgia- David Greene ( 3rd or 4th round) my thinking is Greene is more likely to be there in 3rd or 4th rd. not sure they'll be availible then.

 

[Boone]

neither...

 

[stoody24]

I'd take any of them over Smith/Rodgers honestly

me too

 

[Puffboy(ricky)]

mcpherson

 

[stoody24]

Does anyone have any stats between the two of them????

 

[AZStryker]

Definitely neither! I hope we go with Green or Orten who are more a field general or cerebral QB rather than just pure athletes.

 

[arsenal]

the most important stat was last year campbell completed 70% of his passes, thats a nice stat right there...

 

[Agent51]

the most important stat was last year campbell completed 70% of his passes, thats a nice stat right there...

but you have to look at how many he attampted. It doesnt hold muc to the others if that 70% was o half as many attampts as the other QBs (not an actual stat, just used 1/2 as an example)

 

[poisonphin]

First of all I would rather take Smith. IMO he his as mobile as Cambell and almost as mobile as Mcpherson, but if I had to pick one to take in the third then I would take Cambell because I feel that he is more proven playing football. Mcpherson is good but you can't go by his AFL season. The AFL is a completely differant game. Don't tell me he did good because he threw over 60 TDs. Thats only a pretty good year in the AFL IMO.

 

[FireInTheNole]

Why can't you go by his AFL season?? It's just as good as going by someone’s college career and combine workouts IMO. I just don't think Campbell is that good IMO, I think Ronnie and Caddie made him look good. Plus working out with Warren Moon in the off season help McPherson out alot.

 

[arsenal]

but you have to look at how many he attampted. It doesnt hold muc to the others if that 70% was o half as many attampts as the other QBs (not an actual stat, just used 1/2 as an example)

he had plenty of attempts over 250 and 70% is still sick... lefors was even better last year with like 74% thats ****ing crazy...