CNNSI Ranks The Backup QB's | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

CNNSI Ranks The Backup QB's

I saw a little bit of Daunte playing the other day and he didn't look bad. Honestly I thought that Henne was a little high on that list, primarily for the reasons they stated, he hasn't shown anything yet in the NFL. I was thinking 15 or so.
 
I agree with some of you.

Since when did spending all that time in the slammer make a QB better ?
 
It's amazing how Vick is such a little darling now. Has dog murdering and prison time made him better? I heard some joker on espn the other day say he'd take Vick over McNabb in their primes. That's ****ing absurd. Do we forget that Vick was a borderline bust as a starting QB. I don't question the awesome talent he had coming into the league but it did not translate to him being an effective NFL QB.
 
Now I know that Donovan has laid a few eggs in his career, but the complete lack of respect that guy has gotten from so many is astonishing. How many times has he taken the Eagles to the NFC championship game 4, 5 times? And he did that with no really good receivers and the one year they did have T.O. They went to the Super Bowl. Prior to last year I would have taken him as our QB no questions asked and I'd still seriously consider it now. Donovan is a great QB and the city of Philthadelphia will regret what they lost and did not appreciate when he moves on. It's not so easy to replace a great QB as we well know (not saying he's Marinoesqe).
 
Kiick72 said:
Now I know that Donovan has laid a few eggs in his career, but the complete lack of respect that guy has gotten from so many is astonishing. How many times has he taken the Eagles to the NFC championship game 4, 5 times? And he did that with no really good receivers and the one year they did have T.O. They went to the Super Bowl. Prior to last year I would have taken him as our QB no questions asked and I'd still seriously consider it now. Donovan is a great QB and the city of Philthadelphia will regret what they lost and did not appreciate when he moves on. It's not so easy to replace a great QB as we well know (not saying he's Marinoesqe).
Click to expand...
Agreed. From the minute he stepped into the league, I'm not sure any great QB has ever taken as much **** as Donovan Mcnabb. He has been so far superior to Vick as an NFL QB that it's not even close and yet it's predictable that this situation in philly is going to end with McNabb getting screwed.
 
Honestly, looking over that list, it looks like Joey Harrington made a poor choice in signing with NO. He could have been the backup to probably half those teams instead of 3rd string in NO.

And why the hell is JP Losman in the UFL instead of replacing some of the bums on that list?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom