I'm one of the few that doesn't think Finnegan is a retread. He played poorly last year because of injuries, a broken orbital socket limiting his peripheral vision and a serious hamstring injury. He should have been on IR much sooner, but Fisher allowed him to play. As far as 2012 went, I'm not sure why he is getting a bad rap for that year. He gave up a few big plays, but that has more to do with poor execution of scheme from some of the St Louis safeties. Finnegan was asked to play run support a lot, and that puts a CB at risk unless you have good safeties, which the Rams didn't.