Crazy Hypothetical

[NoblePhin]

Ooooh boy do I goota doozy for you guys. Just noticed Brandon Marshall got cut, Mr. All Day back on the market. So I just have to throw this out, who would you rather have in win now mode, Parker or Marshall?

Marshall is coming off ankle surgery and is winding down his solid career but has said he's got two years left. Meanwhile Parker has flashed, but gets sidelined for nagging injuries every year and disappears for stretches of games. The word potential is starting to turn into a nightmare , I'm starting to get the feeling that he could be a draft day trade, possibly a 4th round pick.

Marshall/Stills/Wilson/Amendola/Grant/ Carroo or another rookie doesn't look bad tbh

 

[artdnj]

Marshall is done imo, don't want him. A 4th is redic...

 

[Crump]

I want marshall to go the patriots,,let him jinx them with his never being to the playoffs self. If we are bringing in and trading Parker for a 4th, I think we should try to get another 4th out of Tanne and bring Cutler back. Cutler and BMarsh always paired well together in a losing effort

 

[Stoobz]

No Marshall please.

 

[rickd13]

Marshall is just a name. He is so washed up. He should retire.

 

[Blackcreekbandit]

Big no to bringing in Brandon Marshall.. I get flashbacks of him flailing his arms presnap demanding the ball go his way before the balls even snapped. Then he goes out and claims there's no room for Dez on the giants. Dude is more worried about losing targets to Dez than he is about improving the overall talent level of his team and giving them a better chance to win. Hard pass.

@NoblePhin shame man i know you're a better poster than this!

 

[claytonduper]

Yes. Crazy hypothetical.

 

[The Ghost]

Certifiably.

 

[bradmcnutt13]

Marshall takes me as the type of guy that would highly overestimate how much he has left.

 

[BIGSHOT]

He is Washed point blank period...

 

[Daytona Fin]

We had him in his prime and it didn't work out. Why would anyone think that 7 years later, at the end of his career, it will be better?

 

[finmann]

Marshall hasn't done much of anything for the last 3 years......no thanks.

 

[Danny]

other than run his mouth what exactly would he do? No thanks

 

[Wishfishin]

The Giants were suckers when they signed him. Let that be the end of it.

 

[BSQ]

not even for free