We all will see first hand this coming season that Ryan Tannehill and Jay Cutler are both above average QBs with Tannehill slightly better than Cutler. Having said that, if things fall into place, i.e., they are on a good team, both QBs would be able to lead their team on a deep playoff run. Tannehill hasn't had the luxury yet of "things falling into place", Cutler had that in 2010 and his team played in the Conference Championship game that year.