Dennis Dixon or Josh Johnson? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Dennis Dixon or Josh Johnson?

#1dolphinsfan

#1dolphinsfan

Perennial All-Pro
Joined
Feb 19, 2007
Messages
8,211
Reaction score
15
Location
Nevada
Assuming they are both there in the 4th round witch one would you wan to take Dennis Dixon is coming off an ACL tear but most QBs come back from that with out a Problem IMO i would Rather Have Dennis Dixon he is a good QB when he was Healthy when he went down the Ducks went down there was no way that Ryan Leafs brother was going to Carrie the Ducks so if they are both there in the 4th round and there are no better QBs witch one would you rather have
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Joshn Johnson has more potential and is not coming off of an injury. If we could get Johnson in the 4th round, I would take him. I think we need to draft a QB at some point in this draft. I am not saying that we know what we have in Beck but we need to add more talent at the QB position.
 
#1dolphinsfan said:
Assuming they are both there in the 4th round witch one would you wan to take Dennis Dixon is coming off an ACL tear but most QBs come back from that with out a Problem IMO i would Rather Have Dennis Dixon he is a good QB when he was Healthy when he went down the Ducks went down there was no way that Ryan Leafs brother was going to Carrie the Ducks so if they are both there in the 4th round and there are no better QBs witch one would you rather have
Click to expand...

Tough question, both quarterbacks seems very similar to each other, but im going to say my mayn man, Josh Johnson. Don't get me wrong, but I really like this guy. He's got more upside, and in mine book he would become a much better passer than Dixon. I've have never liked the scrambling style in NFL, and think the pocket passer is a way better. No one of them would become any great in NFL because of there styles. Josh Johnson might have a chance to get rid of the scrambling style and become an OK pocket passer. Which is a big key in NFL.

So my choice would be Josh anyday over Dixon.
Dixon is true TV star, but he could get serious hurt in NFL. :unsure:
 
Dolfdk said:
Tough question, both quarterbacks seems very similar to each other, but im going to say my mayn man, Josh Johnson. Don't get me wrong, but I really like this guy. He's got more upside, and in mine book he would become a much better passer than Dixon. I've have never liked the scrambling style in NFL, and think the pocket passer is a way better. No one of them would become any great in NFL because of there styles. Josh Johnson might have a chance to get rid of the scrambling style and become an OK pocket passer. Which is a big key in NFL.

So my choice would be Josh anyday over Dixon.
Dixon is true TV star, but he could get serious hurt in NFL. :unsure:
Click to expand...
yea Josh Johnson had the better stats by Far but i dont know who i would take i think it would be Dixon but i think your right it would be a tough choise
 
#1dolphinsfan said:
Assuming they are both there in the 4th round witch one would you wan to take Dennis Dixon is coming off an ACL tear but most QBs come back from that with out a Problem IMO i would Rather Have Dennis Dixon he is a good QB when he was Healthy when he went down the Ducks went down there was no way that Ryan Leafs brother was going to Carrie the Ducks so if they are both there in the 4th round and there are no better QBs witch one would you rather have
Click to expand...

Id rather have Adrian Arrington(6'3",200+ lbs.,compared to Larry Fitzgerald) in the 4th than both those guys
 
DOL-FAN92 said:
Id rather have Adrian Arrington(6'3",200+ lbs.,compared to Larry Fitzgerald) in the 4th than both those guys
Click to expand...
we need a QB somewhere in the draft we need someone to chalenge John Beck for the starting job
 
I would take JJ, he just doesn't throw int's., plus he has a high accuracy rate.

I try to look for value in lower rated players, not 1st rounders and both of these players fit the bill.

Colt Brennan
Josh Johnson
Dennis Dixon
Paul Smith
 
#1dolphinsfan said:
Assuming they are both there in the 4th round witch one would you wan to take Dennis Dixon is coming off an ACL tear but most QBs come back from that with out a Problem IMO i would Rather Have Dennis Dixon he is a good QB when he was Healthy when he went down the Ducks went down there was no way that Ryan Leafs brother was going to Carrie the Ducks so if they are both there in the 4th round and there are no better QBs witch one would you rather have
Click to expand...



Both are accurate and mobile QB's. One thing i can say Johnson may have better than Dixon is he came out of a non shot-gun system and has better footwork as well as can read on the drop-back (please fix me if i am incorrect).

otherwise I like Dixon as a great mature leader, hard worker, and more of an accurate apsser when stepping into everything (sometimes tends to throw off back foot). Dixon is faster and a better runner too (not by much).

darn that injnury for Denny though
 
Johnson. To me he is a player that can make a huge impact in multiple ways. His accuracy is great. I don't care what competition it is against, his TD-INT ratio is amazing.
 
we need a qb... if you say so I guess.

Picking a qb would be a waste of a selection in my opinion.

we have far too many holes to be picking up another qb with a draft choice.

at the very most, bring in a vet FA for competition.

beck had no tools to work with last year, give him time bro. you don't close the book on a guy who you took in the second round, when his best weapon was jesse chatman.

ginn and beck both should be much more productive this year.

adrian arrington would be sweet in the fourth btw... for the guy who mentioned it.
 
WelcomeBack said:
Johnson. To me he is a player that can make a huge impact in multiple ways. His accuracy is great. I don't care what competition it is against, his TD-INT ratio is amazing.
Click to expand...



his TD/INT ratio is basically fictional, it seems impossible... lol
 
JJ also has great speed. His official is not 4.5 but thats damn good for a QB.
 
Picking a qb would be a waste of a selection in my opinion.
Click to expand...

We only have 1 QB. Trent was released and Cleo is a FA and won't be signed.
We did add another QB but he seems destined for the practice squad.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom