This is the great thing about football, so many people can watch the same thing and come up with so many different interpretations.
For instance, Richard brings up the play at 1:40 into the video. Where he sees overpursuit, I see correct gap control. Jarron Baston has the offensive left side A gap on the shoulder of the Center. There's a defensive end lined up real wide that has the outside shoulder of the left tackle, the left side C gap. Who has the B gap on the outside shoulder of the left guard? Sean Weatherspoon. Spoon actually attacks the outside shoulder of the left guard real nicely, right at the line of scrimmage, and even to the point where if the RB had pushed the stretch instead of executing the zone cutback, even if he didn't try to attack Spoon's B gap, if he tried to hit the left side C or D gaps, Spoon probably could have given him some chase and disruption in the backfield to delay the play pretty well. This is gap football.
So why does the play work for Oklahoma State? The other inside backer has the right side A gap, and the LDT actually has the right side B gap. That leaves the LDE with responsibilities on the right side C gap on the inside of the Tight End's shoulder. Oklahoma State has the Tight End release on a pattern and this being a zone play, that LDE has to pay attention to the possibility of Zac Robinson keeping the ball for a boot. What I think you'd like your 3-Technique to be able to do on this play is cause so much havoc that the RG is unable to chip and then release on the ILB to Spoon's left...leaving him free to pursue. Also, the line is able to achieve some pretty good spacing on the play, and in the end the LDE has to be able to clamp down on his gap responsibility without allowing the runner the freedom to run right through it for 5 yards. Could have been better, could have been worse, I wouldn't be faulting Spoon on that one.
Literally almost the same exact thing on the play at 1:46. At the snap he HAS to hit the outside shoulder of the LG. He has to shut that down FIRST because that's his area of responsibility. If he was the type of player that guesses on every play and freelances out two gaps right at the start instead of forcing the runner's hand by shutting his own gap down first...then yeah, he might have made plays at 1:40 and 1:46...but my guess is this highlight tape would have been filled in with a lot more nasty Taylor Mays-looking plays.
I would agree with you about 1:40 except all he does is go up the field without reading the runner at all. Yes he attacks what will likely be the hole for the runner, but at the same time the DT in front of him is doing a good job of controlling his gap and forcing his man into the backfield. If the runner does try to go outside of that, then in all likely hood Spoon can reach him if he is a little more patient to begin the play. It's not all on him, but he does get himself out of position really, as he is way in front of the runner. Spoon doesn't slide a little then come forward, doesn't bounce once to read the runner etc, he's off like a bat out of hell.
He outruns the runner to the spot, he doesn't slide keeping himself parallel with the LOS, he turns and runs, full tilt or at least hell of quick. Thats not showing me a great deal. If I'm the runner, I'm gonna cut the ball back a hell of a alot and be successful at it.
He doesn't crow hop forward, he just flies up the field, and in doing so he is well away from the play. Looking at him film reminds me of Maualuga in that respect, he would see something and fly up the field without reading the action. Yeah it could be the hole, but if you read the runner at all, it will help. That doesn't smell instinctual to me, thats more of flying around the field and making plays in the process IMO.
He's not flowing to the football IMO, he's running hard, but he isn't adjusting to the play as it develops at all. He just goes forward and is no where near the play.
If he was gap conscious, I think he'd be a little less all out like that and read the play via a more traditional slide or scraping action down the line, if he reads Toston continuing to the hole, he has the speed to meet that blocker in the hole. Or at least under cut the guy and cause Toston to bounce or something, even if he doesn't take the pulling lineman on. He's got to run the alley there and fill from the inside, if he tries to get outside first he'll get burned IMO. I just think he's outrunning the play rather than trusting what he sees and then using his speed to fill "the" gap rather than "a" gap. Can he get better? Sure, if he gets the reps, but I don't know if he will be that instinctual on the inside.
The other thing is that who ever is gonna have a good deal of work to get him to bring his hips to the party when he engages, or even to play through the contact rather than to it a good deal. That has to be worked on, and that's an attitude issue in my mind. It could just be who he is, if so, then thats fine, but he won't be playing the Mike with a great deal of success IMO - not unless he gets protected by some behemoths inside.
Again maybe it just me, but he's running to a hole rather than being in the hole. He has to slow down and rely on his speed to take him to what he sees rather than running hard and making plays along the way sometimes. He is better when he is on the outside or in space and the play unfolds in front of him. At times like these he can look deadly.