Edgerrin James
Year Team G GS Att Yards Avg Lg TD 20+ FD
1999 Indianapolis Colts 16 16 369 1553 4.2 72 13 9 79
2000 Indianapolis Colts 16 16 387 1709 4.4 30 13 9 99
2001 Indianapolis Colts 6 6 151 662 4.4 29 3 5 40
2002 Indianapolis Colts 14 14 277 989 3.6 20 2 3 56
2003 Indianapolis Colts 13 13 310 1259 4.1 43 11 3 83
TOTAL 65 65 1494 6172 4.1 72 42 29 357
Ricky Williams
Year Team G GS Att Yards Avg Lg TD 20+ FD
1999 New Orleans 12 12 253 884 3.5 25 2 4 45
2000 New Orleans 10 10 248 1000 4.0 26 8 3 56
2001 New Orleans 16 16 313 1245 4.0 46 6 2 58
2002 Miami Dolphins 16 16 383 1853 4.8 63 16 7 89
2003 Miami Dolphins 16 16 392 1372 3.5 45 9 6 68
TOTAL 70 70 1589 6354 4.0 63 41 22 316
Edgerrin James has outperformed Ricky through 5 years if you look closely to the numbers. Ricky has averaged less than 4 yards per carry 2 years out of 5. Edgerrin has averaged less than 4 yards per carry 1 out of 5 years.
Edgerrin James, though, has only played a full season 2 years out of his 5 year career. Ricky played every game his last 3 seasons while having injury problems his first 2. Not exactly sure if Edgerrin could carry the load like Ricky has for the last 2 years without getting injured. That is the main concern concerning the drop-off between Ricky and the next potential RB, which looks to be Edgerrin in 2005.
Playing in 5 less games, Edgerrin blows Ricky out of the water in runs over 20 yards and does so in First downs as well still leads Ricky in TD's by 1 with 5 less games.. This could be attributed to Edgerrin having Manning and Harrison as well as a team that focuses heavily on its offensive prowess rather than having a dominant defense.
One thing that concerns me with Edgerrin possibly returning to his home in Miami would be his injury history with this run-oriented offense. This offense was built around Ricky's affect on opponents, meaning 8-9 men in the box with Chambers/Boston going deep to exploit it. I don't know that Edgerrin brings that same presence, but he's without a doubt a Top 10 RB that can produce.