ESPN: Five moves each AFC East team should make | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

ESPN: Five moves each AFC East team should make

rent this space

Starter
Club Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2007
Messages
10,760
Reaction score
14,248
Miami Dolphins

1. Restructure Ndamukong Suh's contract
. The only way the Dolphins could sign last year's most prominent free agent was by structuring his deal in a way that would allow them to pay a hefty signing bonus in the second year of the contract. It's somewhat similar to the way the Saints have built their free-agent deals in recent years, and when I'm referencing the Saints in terms of anything cap-related, it's never a compliment. This isn't a particularly clever strategy from the Dolphins, just a dangerous one.

And so, the vast majority of Suh's $23.9 million base salary will turn into a signing bonus. Let's say $20 million, to keep things simple. That will free up $16 million in cap space for the Dolphins this year while adding $4 million to Miami's cap over each of the next four seasons. Suh won't care; he gets a $20 million check now instead of that same $20 million spread over the NFL season. If the Dolphins want to move on from Suh before the end of the deal, though, whatever's left of that signing bonus accelerates onto their cap that year.
Suh's 2016 and 2017 base salaries are guaranteed, which would make cutting Suh a non-starter. In 2018, the Dolphins would pay $22.1 million if Suh was on their roster and ... $22.2 million if they decided to cut him. So that's out. The earliest the Dolphins realistically can move on from Suh would be 2019, at which point they would still owe $13.1 million in dead money. And Year 1 of the Suh experiment in Miami didn't exactly resound with critical acclaim. That's less a reflection of Suh and more on how desperate the Dolphins were to sign him.
2. Cut Greg Jennings and Brent Grimes. Could the Dolphins keep Suh without drastically restructuring his deal? It's possible, but increasingly unlikely, given that they'll want to try and bring back emerging defensive end Olivier Vernon, who quietly had a monstrous season. They'll need the still-to-be-decided cap to come in at the higher end of estimates, move on from the likes of Lamar Miller and clear out as much salary from the roster as possible. Dumping Jennings, who caught just 19 passes last year, is an obvious move that will save the Dolphins $4 million.
Grimes is a far tougher call. The former Pro Bowler is likely Miami's best cornerback, but he slipped badly last season, getting beaten repeatedly for big plays. Miami asks a lot of Grimes, but they were the worst team in the league by DVOA against No. 1 cornerbacks. The Dolphins could save $6.5 million by cutting the 32-year-old Grimes (or $8 million by designating him as a post-June 1 release), but that would leave them in need of another cornerback, which isn't exactly a cheap position to fill.
3. Franchise Olivier Vernon. On the other hand, if the Dolphins do drastically restructure Suh's deal, they could use the cap savings to lock up Vernon on a short-term deal while trying to negotiate a long-term extension. That should come in somewhere around $15 million. It would be an awfully large price to pay for a team that simply doesn't have much money to throw around, but losing a 25-year-old pass-rusher with as much upside as Vernon is even more of a problem.
4. Find a replacement running back for Lamar Miller. Much to the frustration of fantasy owners, the Dolphins never seemed to trust their starting running back, refusing to turn the ball over to Miller for heavy workloads despite his big-play ability and production in smaller samples. As an unrestricted free agent, Miller likely will find a more welcoming locale elsewhere, and we'll get to see if the Dolphins were right.
Miami seems set to turn things over to Jay Ajayi as its primary back, and while Ajayi has the sort of versatility to justify being on the field for all three downs, the Dolphins will need to bring in a second back as support for their sophomore starter. One cheap option -- and it has to be cheap -- would be Ronnie Hillman.
5. Hold on to draft picks. Executive vice president Mike Tannenbaum had a bad habit of trading draft picks away during his time with the Jets, both to trade up in drafts and acquire veterans. Last year, during Tannenbaum's first offseason with the team, they sent a third-round pick to the Saints as part of the deal that swapped Dannell Ellerbe for Kenny Stills; Stills subsequently caught 27 passes during his first year with the team. (To be fair, the Dolphins also acquired two fifth-rounders for a sixth-rounder when they traded down in the second round with the Eagles.)
Miami has all its picks this year, plus an extra seventh-rounder from the Ravens. With a perilously thin roster ravaged by cap issues and bad drafts, it needs all the cheap talent they can get.


http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/1...lls-dolphins-jets-patriots-make-offseason-nfl
 
The only one I truly agree with is 5...
I say bite the bullet on the Suh Contract this year and find the $ from the releases we have made and will make (Coples,McCain etc.)
If Miller leaves I would look for someone like Ivory or Forte not Hillman. Forte might be old but I think he still has some gas in the tank as a complimentary back not one pounding the rock... Gase will tell us that one eventually...
Franchise OV - No thanks... Cut Grimes? Maybe Cut Jennings - Already done.
 
Makes a lot of sense. I'd like the team to keep both Olivier Vernon and Lamar Miller, but that will be tough to do. Vernon should be the priority this offseason.

Don't think the Dolphins will be big players in free agency this offseason, but cap experts can chime in here to see how much money the team may be able to free up.

Biggest point --- Miami needs to build through the draft and do a much, much better job making the right selections.
 
I agree with every one of them. Surely Miller is hard to see go, but we need to not overpay for a RB. OV needs to be locked up as a pass rusher. If we keep one between Miller and OV we keep OV. Jennings is a no brainer. Cut him. Suh restructure is no easy decision because it delays the problem. Basically Miami has to ask itself DO WE ENVISION HIM HERE FOR 4 MORE YEARS. If yes then we can roll the dice and restructure. With Gase and likely Tannenbaum under a three year ultimatum from idiot Ross, I can see no scenario why the brain trust won't restructure. Finally keeping draft picks. Duh. Start multiplying them. For once.
 
I would keep Miller if at all possible, not crazy about paying anything north of $5 million, though. OV I'm not sure, he makes big plays and big mistakes
 
I agree with every one of them. Surely Miller is hard to see go, but we need to not overpay for a RB. OV needs to be locked up as a pass rusher. If we keep one between Miller and OV we keep OV. Jennings is a no brainer. Cut him. Suh restructure is no easy decision because it delays the problem. Basically Miami has to ask itself DO WE ENVISION HIM HERE FOR 4 MORE YEARS. If yes then we can roll the dice and restructure. With Gase and likely Tannenbaum under a three year ultimatum from idiot Ross, I can see no scenario why the brain trust won't restructure. Finally keeping draft picks. Duh. Start multiplying them. For once.

Our trust will restructure , no brain involved. More of the same from the dolphins
 
This article pretty much echoes my thoughts on what we should be doing . . . Although I am currently leaning more towards hanging on to Grimes over cutting simply due to the utter lack of inexperience at the position on this team right now. It is a decision that I am indifferent to, but if you cut him you have to address CB in free agency, and we will see if there is better than Grimes on the market when free agency opens up . . . And if so, with 31 other teams in the mix, And a rising cap, I have my doubts on just how much we come out ahead by replacing him.

But the article nails the Lamar Miller decision, this is not a team that can afford to throw big dollars on a RB right now. You have already invested in Ajayi, pair him with one of these cheap veteran backs and save a few bucks to use on more important things, like a guard.
 
This article pretty much echoes my thoughts on what we should be doing . . . Although I am currently leaning more towards hanging on to Grimes over cutting simply due to the utter lack of inexperience at the position on this team right now. It is a decision that I am indifferent to, but if you cut him you have to address CB in free agency, and we will see if there is better than Grimes on the market when free agency opens up . . . And if so, with 31 other teams in the mix, And a rising cap, I have my doubts on just how much we come out ahead by replacing him.

But the article nails the Lamar Miller decision, this is not a team that can afford to throw big dollars on a RB right now. You have already invested in Ajayi, pair him with one of these cheap veteran backs and save a few bucks to use on more important things, like a guard.

I think Miller would sign here for a reasonable contract, Vernon on the other hand as stated that he's going where the money is. With that in mind, he will cost at least 12MIL per and Im not sure Id want to overpay for a guy who averages around 7-8 sacks a season. In other words, there are better bang for your bucks options IMO
 
I don't like restructuring Suh, mainly because I don't believe we are going to be a winning team this season so take the hit this year. That being said I get it, the team is trying to be competitive.

I'm okay with cutting Grimes and Jennings. I think Grimes may be a June 1st cut depending on how free agency/draft goes.

Do what it takes to get Miller and Vernon under contract. Though I don't like tagging Vernon, he'll be unhappy and would likely bolt in 2017 if things go south this season.

I agree with holding on to draft picks.
 
I like and see us signing Forte. Gase was with him in Chicago and Forte is a better receiving and run through the tackle back. He lacks Miller's speed but I much rather have Forte.
 
I think Miller would sign here for a reasonable contract, Vernon on the other hand as stated that he's going where the money is. With that in mind, he will cost at least 12MIL per and Im not sure Id want to overpay for a guy who averages around 7-8 sacks a season. In other words, there are better bang for your bucks options IMO

If Lamar is willing to stay home at a reasonable deal, then I am all for it. But I think this "wishful thinking" that is going on with him does not necessarily reflect his intentions. He is a mid 20's RB in 2016 . . . it would be surprising for him to not seek out a financially sound deal as this more than likely will be his "major contract" of his career. I just do not believe this is the team to give him that but honestly it is just a projection on my part and I really don't know what the market is for him. I'm thinking north of 7 million per, but maybe with the devaluation of the position it is in that 5 million area.

As for Vernon, I mean I'm really surprised people are so easily willing to get rid of a 25 year old pass rusher who is still approaching the prime of his career. Free agency is what it is, and you can't always bargain bin shop for replacements . . . especially as a pass rusher. He performed at a high level in the 2nd half. You can't look at it as 12 million per year, you have to look at it as, we developed him for peanuts and if we trust our evaluation, he gets paid his market value and it averages out in the end. To lose him for nothing is just plain irresponsible. Contracts are going up, and young pass rushers with untapped potential have value. i mean there are people on here who think we should just resign Shelby, count on Wake, Fede and Damontre Moore . . . . now that is a joke.

The reason why you get rid of Miller easier, is because teams get quality RBs for nothing now a days and Miami has an investment in Jay Ajayi already. Maybe I'm wrong but I honestly feel comfortable with Ajayi taking over the lead role . . . and if he can't, then you draft another one next year . . . teams don't dwell on big running back contracts anymore, however I think this year with all this money out there I could see a team overpaying for a back like Miller . . . we don't have the necessary cap to make that kind of commitment to a position that is the most easily replaceable position in the NFL.

If we keep him, its more because he is a fan favorite and really has earned the right to stay with the team . . . but financially speaking, it's not a great investment for the Dolphins.
 
I like and see us signing Forte. Gase was with him in Chicago and Forte is a better receiving and run through the tackle back. He lacks Miller's speed but I much rather have Forte.

Forte's main issue is health . . . which can't be taken lightly . . . but if I could be guaranteed his health, you aren't losing much of anything by switching backs, and honestly, he is probably a better fit for Ryan Tannehill and the offense we want to run.
 
I don't like restructuring Suh, mainly because I don't believe we are going to be a winning team this season so take the hit this year. That being said I get it, the team is trying to be competitive.

I'm okay with cutting Grimes and Jennings. I think Grimes may be a June 1st cut depending on how free agency/draft goes.

Do what it takes to get Miller and Vernon under contract. Though I don't like tagging Vernon, he'll be unhappy and would likely bolt in 2017 if things go south this season.

I agree with holding on to draft picks.

So I must ask, what is your reasoning for not restructuring Suh? The only one I can think of is, you want the flexibility of being able to cut him in 2019 . . . Miami has to play 3 seasons before that offseason, and I'm confident that they will need cap space during that time and the deal will eventually be restructured at some point . . . may as well do it now . . . this Suh signing was "always" gonna be a deal that lasted the duration of the contract, unless his play completely fell off a cliff before 2020.
 
If Lamar is willing to stay home at a reasonable deal, then I am all for it. But I think this "wishful thinking" that is going on with him does not necessarily reflect his intentions. He is a mid 20's RB in 2016 . . . it would be surprising for him to not seek out a financially sound deal as this more than likely will be his "major contract" of his career. I just do not believe this is the team to give him that but honestly it is just a projection on my part and I really don't know what the market is for him. I'm thinking north of 7 million per, but maybe with the devaluation of the position it is in that 5 million area.

As for Vernon, I mean I'm really surprised people are so easily willing to get rid of a 25 year old pass rusher who is still approaching the prime of his career. Free agency is what it is, and you can't always bargain bin shop for replacements . . . especially as a pass rusher. He performed at a high level in the 2nd half. You can't look at it as 12 million per year, you have to look at it as, we developed him for peanuts and if we trust our evaluation, he gets paid his market value and it averages out in the end. To lose him for nothing is just plain irresponsible. Contracts are going up, and young pass rushers with untapped potential have value. i mean there are people on here who think we should just resign Shelby, count on Wake, Fede and Damontre Moore . . . . now that is a joke.

The reason why you get rid of Miller easier, is because teams get quality RBs for nothing now a days and Miami has an investment in Jay Ajayi already. Maybe I'm wrong but I honestly feel comfortable with Ajayi taking over the lead role . . . and if he can't, then you draft another one next year . . . teams don't dwell on big running back contracts anymore, however I think this year with all this money out there I could see a team overpaying for a back like Miller . . . we don't have the necessary cap to make that kind of commitment to a position that is the most easily replaceable position in the NFL.

If we keep him, its more because he is a fan favorite and really has earned the right to stay with the team . . . but financially speaking, it's not a great investment for the Dolphins.

This is all valid. Were we diverge is 1) How much its going to take to resign Miller 2) Vernon's upside. Bottom line for me I guess is that althoug the RB position is de valued, Miller brings something that is hard to find in the NFL and that is his ability to score from anywhere on the field, he is exceptionnal in that categorie and I beleive the Miller/Ayayi backfield is one with perfect balance. The DE postion on the other hand is one that is over valued and its fine as long as you overpay for special players at the position, Vernon is good, young and does have upside, but is there something he does thats really irreplaceble? I mean I dont see anything special about Vernon and he's been playing with a top5 pass rusher opposite of him his whole career... If we decide to pay him, I hope he proves me wrong...
 
Back
Top Bottom