Fake GM Mondo | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Fake GM Mondo

He makes a good point. I would certainly offer stills 10 and I also agree that Carroo isnt good enough if stills walks
 
I Think everyone is too tough on Carroo. He barely played. He should excel with an expanded role. That role is certainly not as a deep threat though. Its more so redzone, possession, blocking WR type plays
 
I Think everyone is too tough on Carroo. He barely played. He should excel with an expanded role. That role is certainly not as a deep threat though. Its more so redzone, possession, blocking WR type plays

I agree with you, I personally think he will turnout to be an excelling receiver, however I still think Miami needs a speedster.
 
Marques goodwin has a catch radius that rivals mike wallace...no thanks

Markus wheaton now that may interest me...buy low potential high return

If miami must replace the vertical role

If we do go out and do something its pretty damning of what gase thinks of caroo
 
He makes a good point. I would certainly offer stills 10 and I also agree that Carroo isnt good enough if stills walks

Based on what? We haven't seen him play. I agree we shouldn't count on him as the guy, but we definitely can't say confidently what his skills or limitations are yet.
 
Hmmm young cheaper veteran at lb

That sure sounds like aj klein

Everything except the good part :lol:

Need to edit that to average
 
I don't think I can ever remember a WR coming into the league and performing the way Carroo performed (3 receptions) and then coming back in his 2nd year to earn a starting spot and produce.

Reminds me more of Clyde Gates struggles. (He had 2 receptions as a rookie in 2011). He was out of the league in 2014.
 
I think we should worry less about Stills and worry more about Landry. I'm sorry but in my eyes if I have to pick one Stills isn't even in the game.
 
I Think everyone is too tough on Carroo. He barely played. He should excel with an expanded role. That role is certainly not as a deep threat though. Its more so redzone, possession, blocking WR type plays

My issue with relying on Caroo to replace Stills is that he is not the same type of player. He is not a direct replacement for Stills. He can't knock the top off defenses. He's not a speed guy. Caroo may turn out to be a solid player, but he's not plug-n-play.
 
Good article. Well written, informative, and fun! Well done Armando!

The approach is solid. Those are all sound reasons for making those decisions. I'm less excited than Fake GM Mando is about some of those prospects, but that's a solid list without using a draft pick. A Wheaton would be a good solution, and the Wilson and Britt ideas are also worth considering. If we are going with pure speed, I might see what Jakeem Grant can do in the offense before I splash for someone like Goodwin, but hey, he makes good points.

Wide Receiver is one of those key positions that does not have a shortage of players like LT. The size dimensions of LT's mean there are always going to be a shortage. But, with WR's, they're everywhere. They don't all pan out, but we don't need to spend a 1st rounder to get a good prospect. Will we duplicate Stills' production in 2017? Most likely not. But if we need to fill holes, we can find a solution to that position.

I like Stills and wanted to retain him, but the fact of the matter is that he seems to be worth an amount that would be absurd for us to pay. And, he plays a very replaceable position. There are more and more talented WR's coming out of college each year ... that position is slowly going the way of the RB in that it's becoming devalued--but for a different reason. RB's became devalued because of the emphasis on the passing game. WR's are becoming devalued because of the sheer volume of talented and NFL-ready guys coming out of college these days, and that number keeps increasing. As the NFL's appetite for WR's increases from 2 to 3 to 4, the number of good prospects has more than doubled. And, they are entering the NFL much more ready to contribute on day 1 than ever before. The good prospects are no longer a rare commodity. They've become more like CB's, where you can probably never have 'enough' but finding a solid one isn't really that hard. At least, not $12M per season difficult.
 
My issue with relying on Caroo to replace Stills is that he is not the same type of player. He is not a direct replacement for Stills. He can't knock the top off defenses. He's not a speed guy. Caroo may turn out to be a solid player, but he's not plug-n-play.

Even if he could, Carroo would not "replace" Stills. Parker would likely slide into that role with some route modifications as we went to primarily a 2 TE set. Even in 3 WR set, Parker would probably be the flanker with Carroo at split end. Just my opinion.
 
My dream off seasons
Either warlord, Leary or Zeitler
Sign Brandon Williams
Sign aj Klein
Sign Micah Hyde or Truman Johnson
Resign stills
Resign Jenkins and paysinger
Draft lb or guard with picks 1 and 2
Draft pat elefin from Ohio state g/c very god player and great kid

We have money to spend on guard and Brandon Williams
Other signing will not break bank
With above signings we can go edge rusher, LB and guard with first 3 picks. We can even move up in 3rd with one of our 5s to grab someone we really like. In addition trade both 5s for a 4.
Thoughts?
 
Back
Top Bottom