Fins Mock Draft (3/15) | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Fins Mock Draft (3/15)

Stitches

I love Mindwarp
Joined
Nov 5, 2004
Messages
12,057
Reaction score
0
Age
39
Location
Akron, OH
The focus of this draft, considering all our needs, will be players who represent excellent value. That means can mean the ability to serve dual roles, amazing physical potential, ability to start early, and/or long term return.

So without further ado, my Fins mock draft as of 3/15.



Note: I didn't include the Broncos 6th, as it is expected the Wilkinson trade will be voided after tomorrow.


Round 1, pick #9- Ted Ginn, WR, Ohio State University
- What’s got two thumbs, and seems to be a big flip flopper? This guy! That’s right I have gone from wanting Brown, to Landry, to Branch, to Meachem, back to Brown, to Hall, and now to Ginn. Truth be told, I can’t imagine any scenario where I will be unhappy with who the fins draft at #9. Only player I don’t want to see us take, who people have speculated, is Olsen. Blah! Though I was very critical of Ginn during his time at OSU, finding almost any chance to slight him, I simply can’t deny how big a playmaker he is. Aside from Calvin Johnson, Ginn wows like no other. His speed, change of direction skills, and moves with the ball in his hands are simply stunning. I don’t know if I’ve watched someone get to their top speed faster. I know I don’t like the ankle injury, and would like to see him run before the draft, but he is so versatile. If the medical staff clears Ginn, then I would have no qualms about the pick. Ginn could play outside, allowing Chambers to move to the slot, and he can return punts. Though Ginn could return kicks, I’d prefer we sign someone like Hicks from the 49ers to do it, so that Ginn doesn’t take such a pounding. His routes are questionable, as well as his ability to play the jam, but truth be told he didn’t ever have to run disciplined routes and no one dared play him tight. I’m sure both of those things can be worked on, as we have a very good WRs coach. I really just can’t say enough about how psyched I am about pick #9 no matter who it is.

Round 2, pick #40- Aaron Sears, OL, University of Tennessee
- While I would prefer to see Blaylock, Grubbs, or Kalil here I just can’t foresee that happening. And while I personally like Zach Miller, from a value stand point Sears projects to help us more. Sears could play tackle or guard, though likely projects well to guard in the pros (and could move out to tackle in a pinch). Sears is big strong and seemingly fast enough to even pull on occasion. His ability to play two separate positions makes me choose him over Zack Miller. And if anyone still has ill feelings towards Tennessee players after last year, you may want to turn away now.

Round 2, pick #60- Jonathon Wade, CB, University of Tennessee
- With all the top corners off the board prior to pick 40, this spot provides ample opportunity to pick from the next best of the bunch. It really comes down to Wade and Fred Bennett who both put up awesome workouts. Both have everything you can look for from a physical standpoint and just have to put it together. But, the fact that I don’t believe Bennett will still be on the board at 60, and that I feel Wade is a much better tackler makes me give him the nod. Wade has tremendous speed, and that might be what draws me to him. We can certainly use that shut down guy, and I really feel like Wade could develop into that. Plus I bet he’d enjoy working in the same secondary with his former teammate. Maybe Allen could help Wade avoid some of the rookie mistakes that were apparent during his first times on the field.


Round 3, pick #71- Andy Alleman, OL, University of Akron
- Call this a homer pick, I don’t care. Alleman is a legit top 5 guard prospect and the fact he might have the potential to play center in the NFL makes him that much more appealing. Alleman put up great workouts, and played well above his competition level. Plus, we already know Houck has taken an interest in him, and that is enough for me to suspect that Alleman is a very likely candidate for our 3rd round pick.

Round 4, pick #104 - Jon Beck, QB, BYU
- Rookie quarterbacks. It is not something the fins have invested much into over the past decade. While Jon Beck is no Brady Quinn, he would be a great selection at the start of day 2. Put up crazy good numbers while directing BYU’s offense, and showed he could work well with the game on the line (recall his TD pass to Jonny Harline as time expired against Utah). Beck had an impressive combine as well, running reasonably well, and displaying a very strong arm. Beck is smart and very accurate. I think he could certainly develop into a very good quarterback, he just needs time, much like Delhomme and Hasselback (not saying he plays like either).

Round 6, pick #166 - Xzavie Jackson, DE/OLB, University of Missouri
- Not gonna lie, had CK not exposed me to this guy I would never have known he existed. This guy is extremely athletic though, and projects very well to play an OLB position in our defense. He can squat 728 lbs ( a Missouri record) and had very good production as a senior (especially compared to his junior season). Perhaps could be had in the 7th, but I’m picking him here just in case.

Round 7, pick #200 - Dane Uperesa, OL, University of Hawai’i
- Here’s another Houck guy on the OL. Extremely athletic once again, and much like Alabi could develop into an excellent player with a little bit of work. He has quick feet and good hands, as well as tremendous size (6’6†309lbs). While this may seem like a lot of OL to draft, we certainly need the depth, and the risk/reward on all the picks seems to certainly lean towards reward. And considering how hard it is to hit on a player late in the draft, you may as well pick someone you like that you are familiar with, and in this case it is Dane.

Round 7, pick #219 - Antonio Johnson, DT, Mississippi State University
- At 6’3†and 310lbs, Antonio is a big man. He has about everything you could look for physically even if the production isn’t there yet. With Traylor on the outs within the next year or two we can use the depth on the DL, and Johnson may just prove to be as valuable a 7th as Fred Evans. More likely, Johnson would spend a year on the practice squad at least, but he appears to be an upgrade over Vickerson in most areas. The ceiling for Johnson is really up to him which is the bad thing, if he can apply himself and work hard at getting the nuances of the position down, he could be something special in my opinion.
 
Man I hate to say it Stitches, but, I dont like the Ginn pick at 9. Not that I dont like Ginn but just not that high, although I do see what you are saying, its gonna be tough at the 9 spot for us, kinda stuck in the middle. I love your sears pick though. I hate to admit it, but i dont know much about Beck, but i have heard a lot of good stuff about him as well. If you can, fill me in a little bit on him.
 
I like the Uperesa pick also, maybe a great player one day, has upside.
 
Man I hate to say it Stitches, but, I dont like the Ginn pick at 9. Not that I dont like Ginn but just not that high, although I do see what you are saying, its gonna be tough at the 9 spot for us, kinda stuck in the middle. I love your sears pick though. I hate to admit it, but i dont know much about Beck, but i have heard a lot of good stuff about him as well. If you can, fill me in a little bit on him.


And it has taken me like over a month of convincing for me to actually be happy about the Ginn pick. I wanted no part of him at first. Then I just kept watching highlights, and it's hard to not like some of the things he can do.

I don't know a lot about Beck, other than than what I've read on draft sites. I know he had an impressive combine, and it really seems like his draft grade varies from 3rd round to 5th. He seems extremely smart thought, and I really liked what I saw whenever I caught any BYU games. I had actually though he didn't have more than an average arm, but he threw some of the fastest velocity balls at the combine.
 
Meh, its okay I guess. Nothing I'd be too excited about. :wink:

Can't say I'd be too excited about taking a WR not named Calvin Johnson Top 10 when this draft is so deep at that position.

I must ask, why 2 guards? Are you assuming Alabi is our starting LT? Or do you see Sears at Tackle?

Wade wouldn't be too bad in the 2nd but I don't see all those lineman rated higher than Sears AND all the CBs rated higher than Wade all being off the board.

Just seems like something is missing to me.
 
Stitches....very, very good draft!!
The only thing that concerns me is the fact that it now appears that Ginn will not be able to run till around draft time, or some even suggest that maybe not till after the draft. His injury seems mose serious than originally sought. I've been hearing that his stock has been dropping, so if that's the case... i hope we can trade down and get more pics, specially if Peterson slides down to #9.
 
And it has taken me like over a month of convincing for me to actually be happy about the Ginn pick. I wanted no part of him at first. Then I just kept watching highlights, and it's hard to not like some of the things he can do.

I don't know a lot about Beck, other than than what I've read on draft sites. I know he had an impressive combine, and it really seems like his draft grade varies from 3rd round to 5th. He seems extremely smart thought, and I really liked what I saw whenever I caught any BYU games. I had actually though he didn't have more than an average arm, but he threw some of the fastest velocity balls at the combine.
On the Ginn thing...I know man, im kinda with you, its hard if a couple a players are not there to draft anything other than a WR. I mean, a lot of the top guys are at positions we dont have a need for. And true, he is very EXPLOSIVE. We definitely need upgrade, and especially speed upgrade at the WR position and he fits the bill there. I just hate investing a high 1st on a WR thats not real polished, thats my only concern.

On the Beck thing...I too have heard a lot about him, it would be nice to get a guy that late. If Quinn doesnt fall to us, which he probably wont, then we really need to get a QB at some point in this draft.
 
I'm sure we all know how I feel about Ginn at 9 already lol.

Overall, it's an ok mock, but my only problem is the John Beck pick. He's an ok prospect, but he's already 25. I don't know if it's just me, but I'd like someone a little younger if we are going with a project QB.

Some of the OL and the Wade pick are a bit questionable at those points as well.
 
Meh, its okay I guess. Nothing I'd be too excited about. :wink:

Can't say I'd be too excited about taking a WR not named Calvin Johnson Top 10 when this draft is so deep at that position.

I must ask, why 2 guards? Are you assuming Alabi is our starting LT? Or do you see Sears at Tackle?

Wade wouldn't be too bad in the 2nd but I don't see all those lineman rated higher than Sears AND all the CBs rated higher than Wade all being off the board.

Just seems like something is missing to me.

I'd prefer Meacham at Bowe over Ginn from a WR standpoint, but there are just a few things Ginn can do that those guys can't, nor will they ever be able to. And that is the only reason I select Ginn over them.

2 guards, because they can play multiple line positions. Sears I would project as the starting LG, with Alabi at LT, and Sears could be like a utility man should an injury happen at either tackle spot. Alleman, while a guard, is drafted to become a center. He likely could compete for either the RG spot or C spot, but I can't see him starting at either at the beginning of the season.

As for Wade, it's hard to predict who will be left when I am only selecting for one team. If something is missing, by all means make your own. :wink:

(I would still have Wilson and Hughes as available CBs at #60 in my head.)
 
I'm sure we all know how I feel about Ginn at 9 already lol.

Overall, it's an ok mock, but my only problem is the John Beck pick. He's an ok prospect, but he's already 25. I don't know if it's just me, but I'd like someone a little younger if we are going with a project QB.

Some of the OL and the Wade pick are a bit questionable at those points as well.

How do you feel about Ginn? (I really don't know.)

If I had done an entire mock, I doubt the fins would have actually drafted a QB. I might have had us getting like Tim Shaw with that pick. But I know we should draft a QB, and without playing the entire draft out pick by pick, it is hard for me to gauge who will still be where. I do agree his age is something that needs to be considered though.
 
I'd prefer Meacham at Bowe over Ginn from a WR standpoint, but there are just a few things Ginn can do that those guys can't, nor will they ever be able to. And that is the only reason I select Ginn over them.

True statement, but there are many things that Bowe and Meachem can do, that Ginn will probably never be able to. Bowe is an AMAZING blocker for a WR and has still got some speed. That would be something great to have as well.
 
True statement, but there are many things that Bowe and Meachem can do, that Ginn will probably never be able to. Bowe is an AMAZING blocker for a WR and has still got some speed. That would be something great to have as well.

As I said, there are a ton of ways we can go at 9 and I will still be happy. I would be happy even if we got Bowe or Meachem at 9.
 
True statement, but there are many things that Bowe and Meachem can do, that Ginn will probably never be able to. Bowe is an AMAZING blocker for a WR and has still got some speed. That would be something great to have as well.
Yeah, my problem with the WR position is this, who is the truley next best WR. There are several guys all clumped together there IMO.
 
How do you feel about Ginn? (I really don't know.)

I don't like Ginn at 9. He's a great deep threat, I just feel we can have a speedy receiver in Chambers. I don't think Ginn is a polished receiver though. He's an athlete, but I'd rather have a wide receiver, and maybe go after a return specialist later.
 
Back
Top Bottom