For all you RB lovers, here's a list of RB's I would rather have as my starter: | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

For all you RB lovers, here's a list of RB's I would rather have as my starter:

Phanatical

Phanatical

Official Daunte Hater
Joined
Aug 21, 2006
Messages
4,899
Reaction score
3
Location
Louisville
Running Back: 2005 2006 2007 Total YDSTotal TD's
Addai, Joseph N/A 1,081 1,072 2,153 19
Barber, Marion 538 654 975 2,167 29
Bush, Reggie N/A 565 581 1,146 10
Gore, Frank 608 1,695 1,102 3,405 16
Jackson, Steven1,046 1,528 1,002 3,576 26
James, Edgerrin1,506 1,159 1,222 3,887 26
Jones, Thomas 1,335 1,210 1,119 3,664 16
Jones-Drew, M. N/A 941 768 1,709 22
Lewis, Jamaal 906 1,132 1,304 3,342 21
Lynch, MarshawnN/A N/A 1,115 1,115 7
McGahee, Willis 1,247 990 1,207 3,444 18
Parker, Willie 1,202 1,494 1,316 4,012 19
Peterson, Adrian N/A N/A 1,341 1,341 12
Portis, Clinton 1,516 523 1,262 3,301 29
Taylor, Fred 787 1,146 1,202 3,135 13
Tomlinson, L. 1,462 1,815 1,474 4,751 61
Westbrook, Brian 617 1,233 1,333 3,183 17
Williams, Ricky 743 N/A 15 758 6 ​

I'm sure there are others, but that's a good start.

Ronnie's last three years:

Brown, Ronnie 907 1,008 602 2,517 13

Not too great.


​
 
Phanatical said:
Joseph Addai
Marion Barber
Reggie Bush
Kevin Faulk
Frank Gore
Steven Jackson
Edgerrin James
Thomas Jones
Maurice Jones-Drew
Willis McGahee
Adrian Peterson
Clinton Portis
Fred Taylor
Ladanian Thomlinson
Brian Westbrook
Ricky Williams

I'm sure there are others, but that's a good start.
Click to expand...

I could name thousands of sensemore threads than this one.

..
 
Joseph Addai - I like Addai, he's alright by me.

Marion Barber - Who wouldn't want Marion Barber?

Reggie Bush - Hugely overrated. You wanna talk about Ronnie not living up to #2 overall?

Kevin Faulk - Sucks

Frank Gore - Great back, is going to get lost in the shuffle with retard Mike Martz.

Steven Jackson - Greedy whore, but still a good running back.

Edgerrin James - In the twilight of his career.

Thomas Jones - Solid back.

Despite all that, I still want Ronnie Brown.
 
Joseph Addai - no
Marion Barber - no
Reggie Bush - no
Kevin Faulk -seriously?
Frank Gore - no
Steven Jackson - maybe
Edgerrin James - no
Thomas Jones - no
Jamaal Lewis - no
Marshawn Lynch - no
Maurice Jones-Drew - maybe
Willis McGahee - no
Adrian Peterson - yes
Clinton Portis - no
Fred Taylor - no
Ladanian Thomlinson - yes
Brian Westbrook - no
Ricky Williams - maybe

in other words, that list sucks.
 
LOL. more ridiculous comments by you.. You'd rather have McGahee who averages less than 3 yards a carry in 4th quarters and routinely elects to take himself out late in games?

The old and worn out Edgerrin James ? LOL

It's funny you bring up Fred Taylor, because that's a guy who had a lot of injuries early in his career and missed a lot of time.. But don't let logic get in the way of anything..

And the list of "some" of those other one dimensional backs like Kevin Faulk ? LOL

What a joke.. Look at the respect Ronnie gets from other observers who are not dolphins fans who have a clue ( a lot of people would LOVE to have him, some comparing him to the next LT, some saying he is a top 5 back etc)-

http://www.footballsfuture.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=250804

and

http://www.footballsfuture.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=250429&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=15

But your credibility has already been flushed down the toilet.
 
Phanatical said:
Joseph Addai
Marion Barber
Reggie Bush
Kevin Faulk
Frank Gore
Steven Jackson
Edgerrin James
Thomas Jones
Jamaal Lewis
Marshawn Lynch
Maurice Jones-Drew
Willie Parker
Willis McGahee
Adrian Peterson
Clinton Portis
Fred Taylor
Ladanian Thomlinson
Brian Westbrook
Ricky Williams

I'm sure there are others, but that's a good start.
Click to expand...

Call espn- they got themselves a headline. Phanatical says ronnie brown is average. Im sure the boadcast will draw HUGE numbers
 
Phanatical said:
Joseph Addai
Marion Barber
Reggie Bush
Kevin Faulk
Frank Gore
Steven Jackson
Edgerrin James
Thomas Jones
Jamaal Lewis
Marshawn Lynch
Maurice Jones-Drew
Willis McGahee
Adrian Peterson
Clinton Portis
Fred Taylor
Ladanian Thomlinson
Brian Westbrook
Ricky Williams

I'm sure there are others, but that's a good start.
Click to expand...

Joseph Addai = Yes. But Ronnie would do good on the Colts as well. Playing with Peyton is a big bonus.
Marion Barber = No way. Slower, less dynamic version of Ronnie.
Reggie Bush = No way. Not interested in 3.1 yards per carry for a career.
Kevin Faulk = No way. A nice 3rd down back who catches well.
Frank Gore = Probably
Steven Jackson = Yes
Edgerrin James = Too old. Give me Ronnie at this point.
Thomas Jones = I'd rather have Ronnie. Jones is above average, that's all.
Jamaal Lewis = This may be his last year. Give me Ronnie.
Marshawn Lynch = Had a good first year. We'll see from here. Yes for now.
Maurice Jones-Drew = Nice back. Roughly equivalent to Ronnie.
Willis McGahee = Roughly equivalent. Ronnie is younger.
Adrian Peterson = Of course.
Clinton Portis = Getting older, but yes.
Fred Taylor = Too old.
Ladanian Thomlinson = Of course.
Brian Westbrook = Looks good in his system. Not sure about here though.
Ricky Williams = About as unreliable as Ronnie.

I'm tired of Dolphin "fans" hating on our players so much. You guys get more satisfaction from certain players failing than from the team winning. If you have such a problem with some of the players on this team, there are 31 other teams out there.
 
Remember Ronnie a year ago, behind a suspect line? Was there anybody that looked stronger in the entire leage? Lets pretend he heals, and recovers form; add Jake Long, RW to share, Smiley, and Chad Pennington, plus smart coaching, and I wouldnt want to be facing Ronnie Brown in any hot Sunday afternoon !!
 
Greyboy said:
LOL. more ridiculous comments by you.. You'd rather have McGahee who averages less than 3 yards a carry in 4th quarters and routinely elects to take himself out late in games?

The old and worn out Edgerrin James ? LOL

It's funny you bring up Fred Taylor, because that's a guy who had a lot of injuries early in his career and missed a lot of time.. But don't let logic get in the way of anything..

And the list of "some" of those other one dimensional backs like Kevin Faulk ? LOL

What a joke.. Look at the respect Ronnie gets from other observers who are not dolphins fans who have a clue ( a lot of people would LOVE to have him, some comparing him to the next LT, some saying he is a top 5 back etc)-

http://www.footballsfuture.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=250804

But your credibility has already been flushed down the toilet.
Click to expand...


Last year McGahee had 1,207 yards, a 4.1 YPC, and 7 TD's. Much more production than Ronnie has ever had.

The "old and worn out" James had 1,222 yards and 7 TD's, yep, the old machine still bested Brown by a long shot.

The injury ridden Taylor also had 1,202 yards, 5.4 YPC and 5 TD's last year, again, much better than Ronnie has ever produced.

Don't let facts get in the way of your opinion.

LOL

GO PHINS~!
 
ticophin said:
Remember Ronnie a year ago, behind a suspect line? Was there anybody that looked stronger in the entire leage? Lets pretend he heals, and recovers form; add Jake Long, RW to share, Smiley, and Chad Pennington, plus smart coaching, and I wouldnt want to be facing Ronnie Brown in any hot Sunday afternoon !!
Click to expand...

Yeah, "let's pretend" he might break 1,000 yards one season.....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom