For those that think Matt Ryans stats make him a bad prospect | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

For those that think Matt Ryans stats make him a bad prospect

dlockz

dlockz

Hall Of Famer
Joined
Sep 6, 2004
Messages
52,028
Reaction score
3,954
Age
58
Location
Tampa Fl
This one will come out better lol


Prospect a

att comp pct yds td int
Fr 222 130 .586 1680 10 9
So 224 116 .518 1609 15 14
Jr 380 226 .595 2876 37 23
Sr 378 221 .584 2432 17 23


TOTAL 1204 693 .576 8597 79 69



Prospect b
att comp pct yds td int
so 415 228 .549 2914 16 18
jr 351 206 .587 2567 13 12
sr 489 309 .632 3942 33 10

total 1255 743 .592 9423 62 40



Prospect c


att comp pct avg td int
fr 71 35 .493 350 2 3
soph 195 121 .621 1514 8 5
jr 427 263 .616 2942 15 10
sr 654 388 .593 4507 31 19

1347 807 .599 9313 56 37



Care to guess the players. if we are to use college stats to choose our Qb then we should be all over colt Brennan.
 
Matt Ryan plays total crap for 3/4 of the game. He is not that accurate. Care to please tell what sets him apart from Brian Brohm? I'd be pissed if they draft, though i'd support him.

Seriously what sets him apart from other qb prospect.
 
I agree I would not want the Fins to Draft him but I will support him just as I did Ted Ginn. Wanna tell us who owns the stats... and if you throw 19 INT and 31 TD like Ryan did, on a poor team such as the Dolphins he throws 25 INT maybe 19 TD (Pushing it) not buying you case.
 
84needs1000yds said:
I agree I would not want the Fins to Draft him but I will support him just as I did Ted Ginn. Wanna tell us who owns the stats... and if you throw 19 INT and 31 TD like Ryan did, on a poor team such as the Dolphins he throws 25 INT maybe 19 TD (Pushing it) not buying you case.
Click to expand...


Derek Anderson threw tons of picks in college and as a first year starter threw 19.

The players were A Marino B Palmer C Ryan
 
And I wouldn't want Derek Anderson to be the Fins QB either... nor do I think he is all he is cracked up to be... yes he made the pro bowl but look at the last few games when he had to get the job done he threw the game away.
 
Who exactly said "his stats make him a bad prospect"??

Or is this just sensationalism non-rationalism.
 
84needs1000yds said:
And I wouldn't want Derek Anderson to be the Fins QB either... nor do I think he is all he is cracked up to be... yes he made the pro bowl but look at the last few games when he had to get the job done he threw the game away.
Click to expand...


Yea your right Beck is so much better. Hell if Marino was in this years draft im sure some people would be talking about his interceptions. If Beck has the season that Anderson had last year, you wont be able to quit talking about his greatness.
 
I've never felt that Ryan is a bad prospect. I've simply stood by the fact that he's not worth the $$$ demanded by a #1 pick. Statistically, it's not smart to purchase a QB for 10's of millions of dollars more, when they are not an "upgrade" to the guy drafted at #40 last year. He's just simply not worth THAT much more, if at all.

I wish Ryan all the best in his career, wherever that might be, even in Miami. But not at #1. I'd question their business smarts if they took him so high.
 
NewPhinPhan said:
I've never felt that Ryan is a bad prospect. I've simply stood by the fact that he's not worth the $$$ demanded by a #1 pick. Statistically, it's not smart to purchase a QB for 10's of millions of dollars more, when they are not an "upgrade" to the guy drafted at #40 last year. He's just simply not worth THAT much more, if at all.

I wish Ryan all the best in his career, wherever that might be, even in Miami. But not at #1. I'd question their business smarts if they took him so high.
Click to expand...

None of these rookies are worth the money. The only high picks that earned thier money last year were Adrian Peterson and Patrick willis.

Who says Ryan is not an upgrade of Beck, thats all about opinion and scouts seem to have Ryan rated much higher than Beck ever was. That was the logic of the fins when we passed on drew Brees that he was not an upgrade over Fielder.
 
Colorado Dolfan said:
...and some are making too much of his intangibles. :foundout:
Click to expand...


Well He is rated high for something. Im not the person that has Ryan rated as one of the best prospects, these are actual people that do this every year. He does have great intangibles, decent td to int ratio , good comp pct and tuff as hell playing with a broken foot most of last year.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom