He's 30, that's not exactly ancient (the tackles you suggested are 31 and 29) and coming off a pro bowl season ( I know it's a popularity contest but still you have to admit he's pretty good). I am a big believer in having experience mixed in with young talent in order to transition your young guys into pros. Good coaches are required for development but I truly believe a vet is a must as well. As he is coming from the SF system what better player to have to teach your young line the intricacies of the scheme. Now I get it, he's more of a nice to have as both OT's and center are more important to resolve but I think you could work in an out in his contract after a year or two after our young guys have developed and are ready to take over. All that said this was only the scenario where we sign Duane Brown and Morgan Moses. If you're going to pony up the money to get Fisher (31 yrs) and Trent Brown (29 yrs) then they probably can't afford Tomlinson. If we went with the guys you have suggested (E. Fisher, J. Daniels and T. Brown) we're looking at $36.5M based on values in my OP. That's in line with the total I had ($34M) which as I mentioned I could get behind. Only problem with this scenario is that Grier has to admit that Ajax is a bust to Ross as Fisher is a longer term solution and that Trent Brown hasn't had a ton of experience in WZ (Fisher did in KC I believe).