I thought Cutler was the best move at the time personally, but the fact is that Cutler has been bad and we're now 10 million dollars poorer in cap space. The person who made the decision to bring in Cutler needs to be the one who is held accountable for it.
Should we fire him over it? No. But we should remember that he was the one who drove a personnel move that turned out to be a net negative for the team.
I wouldn't even call Cutler's play this year bad. He has fought through poor coaching in regards to scheming, players not blocking, way too many dropped passes and way too many untimely penalties. I would say Cutler has been below average but certainly not bad. He's up and down his whole career so we shouldn't be surprised. He hasn't had a bad career either. He's just average and had few above average years.