Good article on the offensive line | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Good article on the offensive line

DolfinDave

FinHeaven VIP
Joined
Jul 22, 2006
Messages
3,914
Reaction score
0
Location
Memphis
Hey guys. Ran across this article on the oline. It analyzes every position on the line and how that affected the running and passing game.

http://www.footballoutsiders.com/2006/10/11/ramblings/every-play-counts/4370/


"After watching the line on every play of Sunday’s 20-10 loss to the Patriots, it appears that the pass protection problems of the first four games were at least as much about Culpepper’s habit of holding onto the ball too long as about the protection he got. But if the pass protection is a bit better than advertised, the run blocking is worse. The Dolphins line will prevent running back Ronnie Brown from showing the talents that made him a top-5 pick last year."


"With left tackle L.J. Shelton next to James, the Dolphins have one of the worst left sides of any line in the league. Shelton made two bad plays that precipitated Harrington’s interception in the second quarter. It’s not Shelton’s fault that Harrington threw a pick, but the Dolphins’ early game plan revolved around picking up a few yards on first and second down to avoid putting Harrington in third-and-long situations. It worked well in the first quarter, and Harrington was having an efficient game, but a Shelton false start turned a third-and-5 into a third-and-10, and that led Harrington to take the chance that became the interception."


"You can’t argue with the past success of Dolphins offensive line coach Hudson Houck, who was the coach of a great Dallas Cowboys line from 1993 to 2001. But this year’s line doesn’t look well-coached. Houck shouldn’t receive too much of the blame, though, as the Dolphins have had bad luck with injuries to linemen this season."
 
Good thread, post. Houck has had to deal with a lot of injuries, but things SHOULD improve as the OL plays together more, like they did last year.
 
i like the thread man. hope daunte learns a thing or two from ( cough) joey..
 
Unfortunately, I have not had opportunity to actually watch any game except Pittsburg this year. I am speaking not on what I have seen, but what I keep reading and hearing.

From what I understand, Shelton is doing a terrible job, especially in pass blocking. However, from what I have heard, he is a strong run blocker, especially for a left tackle. In the meantime, McIntosh was, in my opinion, adequate, to slightly less than adequate at LT last year. He was not "terrible."

I have a question based upon this and I am hoping someone has a GOOD answer. Why not move Shelton down the the RG position, since he is a run blocker who is having trouble in space and move McIntosh back to his more natural LT postion where he is at least adequate, or closer than Shelton?
 
Nice article. The stat of Harrington playing better from under center and Culpepper playing better from the gun has me thinking that perhaps Culpepper isn't as accustomed to playing behind a bad offensive line as Harrington is. There is no doubt in my mind that Culpepper is a better passer then Harrington but I believe that Harrington gets the ball out quicker and therefore will be more successful until we get our O-line on the right track. I think that Saban probably feels the same way and therefore is waiting for Culpepper to gain his mobility back so that he can buy enough time to showcase his talents.
 
I hope the Ronnie haters read this. BTW, you can't help but laugh when you read some of the blurbs about Shelton and James....it really is sad.

"Later in the quarter, when Ronnie Brown took a handoff on a sweep around the left side, Shelton and James doubled Colvin, but Colvin stood his ground, forcing Brown to the inside, where Vince Wilfork and Tedy Bruschi tackled him. When you’ve got two linemen blocking a linebacker and they can’t move him, you’ve got a problem."
 
Shelton is so good he was cut from two very crappy teams:rolleyes:
 
I think Saban should get 1 more year to get this line sured up, but after that he needs to be held accountable for the line that he is putting together. We need to quit picking up all the O-Line players that arn't worth a crap and trying to turn them into probowlers. As soon as we replace the line again next year though were going to be right back into the same problems that we have now when they are trying to gel together, and we'll suck again next year.
 
this is a fantastic article. It is possibly the best oline commentary I have read.

When I read "on a sweep left Shelton and James double teamed Colvin and he held his ground and forced the play inside" I laughed. How can those two be so pathetic to not even move a 250 lbs linebacker. One of them should be able to man handle him. That is exactly what is wrong with our run blocking.

Or on the first Joey Harrington interception. No wonder he threw a pick. They rushed 3 and got pressure with two. You get the same pressure that a 6 man rush would have brought but you were able to keep 8 guys back in coverage. That is just pathetic.
 
dplunk said:
"You can’t argue with the past success of Dolphins offensive line coach Hudson Houck, who was the coach of a great Dallas Cowboys line from 1993 to 2001. But this year’s line doesn’t look well-coached. Houck shouldn’t receive too much of the blame, though, as the Dolphins have had bad luck with injuries to linemen this season."

I don't agree about the injuries - who has been hurt? McKinney - all of us wanted him gone - now because he got hurt people are using that as an excuse - he was not that good. Anderson? He is a load and was getting beat - no big loss there. Berger? Toledo? Both unproven - haven't done a thing to warrant a starting job or to give any reason that they would be an upgrade.

Basically we have some talent on our line - I keep saying it over and over - you can't have a good line without a very good center and we don't have one! Hadnot on his best day is average. Until we pick one up we will be at best average up front IMO.
 
Cutthroat said:
Unfortunately, I have not had opportunity to actually watch any game except Pittsburg this year. I am speaking not on what I have seen, but what I keep reading and hearing.

From what I understand, Shelton is doing a terrible job, especially in pass blocking. However, from what I have heard, he is a strong run blocker, especially for a left tackle. In the meantime, McIntosh was, in my opinion, adequate, to slightly less than adequate at LT last year. He was not "terrible."

I have a question based upon this and I am hoping someone has a GOOD answer. Why not move Shelton down the the RG position, since he is a run blocker who is having trouble in space and move McIntosh back to his more natural LT postion where he is at least adequate, or closer than Shelton?

I've wondered that too. The weird thing is MacIntosh has never been in favor with Huock. I am not sure why. He was not good last year but after seeing Shelton play I am kind of baffled at how he took the starters job. Just like the QB position I think they are due for a shakeup and at this point it couldn't get that much worse. Try Berger at LG and maybe put DMac back at LT. I know this messes with chemistry which is vital but at least Dmac has played LT before and like I said they couldn't get that much worse.
 
Back
Top Bottom