Good comparisons! Smith and Harrison, Chase and Fitzgerald, Pitts and Burress! | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Good comparisons! Smith and Harrison, Chase and Fitzgerald, Pitts and Burress!

BIGFINS

BIGFINS

Rookie
Club Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2007
Messages
233
Reaction score
248
www.espn.com

Who do Mac Jones, DeVonta Smith and Kyle Pitts compare to best? 10 NFL draft matches

Ten of our NFL draft analysts weighed in with their favorite prospect/NFL player comps for this year's class, including matches for Mac Jones, Kyle Pitts and more.
www.espn.com www.espn.com

I really like the comparisons for Devonte Smith = Marvin Harrison, Jamar Chase = Larry Fitzgerald....

Jaylen Waddle = Tyreek Hill would be Amazing if we could get him in a trade down.

Kyle Pitts = Plaxico Burress is not that exciting. Plaxico was pretty good but not great!

My favorite and most realistic is Smith becoming a Marvin Harrison type Pro Bowl receiver.
He just looks like a EXTREMELY polished player in the football field no matter what his size is just like Marvin....
 
Every single 100+ catch or 1000+ yard or 10TD+ season Harrison had in his career was with Manning at QB. Fitzgerald on the other hand, spent most of his career playing with literal scrubs. Sure he had Kurt Warner and Carson Palmer for a few seasons. He also had 13 other scrub QBs in there before Murray came along. These comparison things are just for our amusement obviously, but Fitzgerald shouldn’t even be in the same conversation as Harrison IMO.
 
Not my favorite comps.

Smith's game is so much more physical than Harrison's. Smith is fantastic at contested catches and that was never Harrison's game. Lately I've been seeing more of Davante Adams. Both of those guys are great at getting of the line/off of press and have great hands.

Chase is similar to Fitzgerald, but the young version who was much quicker. Even then Chase has better YAC ability than Fitz ever had although I think Fitz's hands were more consistent.

Pitts is far more explosive than Burress ever was. IMO Waller is the best comp for him.
 
rafael said:
Not my favorite comps.

Smith's game is so much more physical than Harrison's. Smith is fantastic at contested catches and that was never Harrison's game. Lately I've been seeing more of Davante Adams. Both of those guys are great at getting of the line/off of press and have great hands.

Chase is similar to Fitzgerald, but the young version who was much quicker. Even then Chase has better YAC ability than Fitz ever had although I think Fitz's hands were more consistent.

Pitts is far more explosive than Burress ever was. IMO Waller is the best comp for him.
Click to expand...


I see Waller as Pitts' floor
 
Smith = Harrison
Chase = Irvin
Waddle = Tyreek Hill
Pitts = Mike Evans
 
I think Waller is a better comp for Pitts. I think his ceiling is higher than Waller.

Smith and Harrison is good. I see Warfield in Smith as well, with his gliding, smooth, effortless speed.

Chase is a tougher comparison. I don't think he's as good as Larry Fitzgerald, but run after the catch is fantastic. That might be where Chase compares favorably.
 
Pitts = Shannon Sharpe, unless you're a younger fan. Then, yeah, Waller is the closest.
 
Your comps are way off.

Chase is 3 inches shorter than Fitz

Pitts is bigger and plays a different position than Plaxico.

Marvin Harrison was 20 lbs heavier than Smith.

Waddle and Hill is the only one that comes close and its a long shot Waddle ever gets close to as good as Hill, but ill give you this one.

Actual Comps.

Pitts = Shanon Sharpe
Smith = Issac Bruce
Chase = O'Dell Beckham
Waddle = Stephon Diggs
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom