Grade Our Draft | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Grade Our Draft

Majpain

Majpain

Giants GM
Joined
Oct 21, 2005
Messages
15,935
Reaction score
0
Age
35
Location
Alabama
Day 1-B
Day 2-C

I maybe the minority on day 2 but I really didn't like most of our picks.

I cant believe we pasted on Allan in the 7th. I really thought they would have draftd a TE and a CB

Who I want to see as a UDFA

Chase Johnson OT - Is a monster just need to BULK up big time. If he was stronger he would have been a 1st round pick. He is 6'8 330 pounds!

Selvin Young RB - Put him on the practice squad Young has to much talent.

Matt Trannon WR - at 6'6 ran a 4.54 who needs work.
O R
Rhema Mcknight WR - 6'1 4.55 is a Great athlete. Great blocker and Good body control. Would be a posession WR

Johhny Harline TE - get this guy he played with Beck. They are teammates.

Tim Duckworth OG - Cant believe he fell

Tala Esera OG - He is out of Hawaii thats a automatic sign.

Bo Smith S - Only why he wasnt drafted was character concerns.
 
Overall I give the draft a B-. I think we got some very solid prospects in this draft.
 
I would say overall I would give them a grade of B. I think a lot of it will only be known over time, but I really love Beck as our future QB....he has a nice arm, decent speed....I would say he is as athletic as Tom Brady and can put the ball anywhere with zip and accuracy.

I love Ginn and the speed he gives us. He and Chambers give us a deep threat anytime.

I am not crazy about us grabbing two running backs in Lo Booker and the guy from Hawaii,,,,,but hopefully one of these backs will be our 3rd down and short guy....the guy from Hawaii (Reagan M.) is a real bowling ball like Iron Head Hayward. I hope we can get O-lineman Tala Esera of Hawaii as a free agent, also Harline, the TE from BYU would be worth a shot. Also we have a new punter in Fields....he can flat out boom it. :)
 
Anyone else want Mcknight and Chase Johnson?

I'm really excited about the UDFA's this year.
 
i havent really compared who we got to who we passed on in most picks yet... but just judging by what we got with each pick i'd give us :

Day 1 : B+ or maybe A... Sure we took all 15 min. at 9 to try and trade down only a few spots for Ginn... but like Mueller said it takes two to trade... we had to have our guy. Beck we got lucky on i guess... Satele i love.... we needed a guy like him. And then theres Booker who i had a feeling we'd be interested in, i was watching his highlights days before the draft after i saw his pre-draft interview... He's a steal no doubt.

Day 2 : C- liked the Solai pick, but suprised T Free was there and we passed. I'm not sure about the Reagan Mauiai pick. The rest looks like nice solid depth and a much need punter.
 
C-/D, I only like the Beck pick after that the major areas of concern where not addressed, no CB,NT, LT...
and I still cant get over the reach for ginn..
 
Love it.....this draft is a solid A, and could be a firm A+ in hindsight.

I love the speed and playmakers we added to O side (and special teams), love the OL (C/G) versatility. A big bruising FB body, and our QB of the future.

The DT, ILB, and DE picks showed nice value. And finally a P, no problems there.

Great job by our FO.
 
I would love to pick up Young and KcKnight.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom