Grading the Dolphins | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Grading the Dolphins

phinphanforever

Banned forever....
☠️ Banned ☠️
Joined
Sep 27, 2006
Messages
745
Reaction score
0
Location
Montreal, PQ
QB- B+. HArrington's best game as a fin. Managed the game very well. Game plan called for Harrington to make alot of throws, and apart from thae one pick (:shakeno: he seems to do this every week) , he made solid decisions. The Chambers TD called back was a nice play.

RB- C Hard to evaluate R Brown today. The fins never had any intention of running, and when they thought they might be able to, they got squat.

WR- B+. The unit played very well today. Route running was disciplined and they hung on to the ball, with the exception of that one drop by Welker.

O-line- B. Very nice job in pass protection. The Minni D is not known for getting a lot of pressure but gioven the amount of times Joey threw the ball, the O-line played comnsistent pass proterction. Run Blocking was non existant

Secondary B- Very solid play. Bell's insertion inot the lineup has really changed things. He has a real nose for the ball. Cbs could have done a better job in run support.

Linebackers- B+- Zach had a solid game and Spargan played above himself. Pope filled in well for Crowder.

D-line.-A+ The loss of Tractor was really evident in the first half, but J Taylor -once again- came up with some monster plays and changed the complection of the game. Holliday, Roth and Carter all made some very big plays.
I still am shaking my head at all those on this site who wanted to trade him a few weeks ago. The bottom line is that JT is playing the best football of his already sterling career. He has to be considered the defensive MVP of the league. He is flat out dominating.

ST- C+ Mare continues to struggle, and I thought Jones did nto have a very good game. Coverage was not great but Jones' kicks were short. Return game was average.

Coaching: A. Once again, the coaching staff came up with a solid game plan especially the offense in first half and the defense in second). Team had another week of very few penalties.

Overall- B+. As Saban said, today's game really showed the team's ability to fight through some adversity. The first series was a real blow to the psyche (fumbling on 1 and then Minni marches 96 yards for a score) but the team responded well. The game was decided by JT. The team will have to get back to running the ball against Detroit.
 
i would give the team a solid B

the running game: D-
harrington: c- he had a good first half and then gave points to the vikings like he gave the bears that if not for the d could have been bad
wr: B+ welker and booker had very good games
defense: B+ need to tighten up on the running game
st: c mare is ****ing up big time

jason taylor;A++++++++++++++++++++++++
 
qb - "C" (A - 1st half F- 2nd half) touchdowns that are called back don't count.
rb - "F"
wr - "C"
ol - "D"
dl - "A-" got pushed around early but came back and made the game winning plays.
lb - "B"
secondary - "B"
st's - "C" - the vikes consistently made good returns and of course mare missing the fg.
coaching - "C" the defense made solid adjustments as the game went on. the offense got worse.
Bottom line: offense scored 10 points and continues to be mediocre. The defense bailed us out with a win "Chicago Bear" style.
 
JT won't get consideration for Defensive POY unless Dolphins make the playoffs. It's just a sad reality of our country's media.
 
How could anyone give anything but an F to the running game is beyond me. I


I'm not saying is not justified because Ronnie was injured and so is James and minny has a good D. But still -3 yards is an F man. I mean really if -3 yards is a C what the hell is an F.
 
The defense made plays when they had today, they deserve all of the credit for this win. Joey did make some good plays but kind of fell of in the 2nd half.
 
elite14eva said:
mare has to go asap.

and replace him with?????


and THIS is a fair question...
lereux said:
How could anyone give anything but an F to the running game is beyond me. I


I'm not saying is not justified because Ronnie was injured and so is James and minny has a good D. But still -3 yards is an F man. I mean really if -3 yards is a C what the hell is an F.
 
brandon1986 said:
harrington: c- he had a good first half and then gave points to the bears that if not for the d could have been bad

Are you sure you watched the right game? :sidelol:
 
Coaching deserves a d at best, spread offense played lightsout then abandoned it for playaction when we have -13 yards rushing! Horrible playcalling.
 
Aqua4Ever04 said:
I think you are the one watching the wrong games.

:shakeno: Pretty sure, I watched the Phins and the Vikings not the Bears :sidelol:
 
bluehaze said:
Are you sure you watched the right game? :sidelol:

my bad i meant to say gave points to the vikings like he did against the bears
 
Back
Top Bottom