harrington and the 1st rounders | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

harrington and the 1st rounders

R

rob banks

Starter
Joined
May 10, 2006
Messages
145
Reaction score
0
Age
44
Location
dallas TX
ok... all i hear is he had 3 recievers that were 1st round picks and still couldn't win games... ok here's the question... who says the 3 recievers are so great??.. they haven't showed me anything and none of them have made the pro bowl... just because your a 1st round pick doesn't mean you will be a great player... i know rodgers has had a tough career with the injuries and roy williams shows talent.. but they still aren't great players yet... was it joey's fault?? maybe.. maybe not.



www.myspace.com/jonesforme
 
Yeah....

But you can't dispute the fact that Joey played terribly. That's not to say that it was all his fault, but he showed very little to make me believe he could ever be a starting NFL quarterback. Thank god we have Daunte whom on the other hand has shown all it takes to be a great NFL QB. I hope Joey is a decent backup for us, but Nick Saban knows he is just a short term solution to a short term problem. If Daunte ever goes down, at least we have an experienced backup instead of throwing Cleo out there to the wolves.
 
yea i completely agree, what says that they cant be busts...i know that they all have shown talent and esspecialy in college but joeys not the only qb on the lions who found difficulty connected with his recivers but when jeff garcia was put in to replace harrington he would constantly get annoyed and frustrated with his wrs
 
rob banks said:
ok... all i hear is he had 3 recievers that were 1st round picks and still couldn't win games... ok here's the question... who says the 3 recievers are so great??.. they haven't showed me anything and none of them have made the pro bowl... just because your a 1st round pick doesn't mean you will be a great player... i know rodgers has had a tough career with the injuries and roy williams shows talent.. but they still aren't great players yet... was it joey's fault?? maybe.. maybe not.



www.myspace.com/jonesforme
Click to expand...

Charles Rodgers vs CHRIS CHAMBERS
Roy Williams vs. MARTY BOOKER
Mike Williams vs. DEREK HAGAN

you do the math :wharf:
 
miaD5499 said:
yea i completely agree, what says that they cant be busts...i know that they all have shown talent and esspecialy in college but joeys not the only qb on the lions who found difficulty connected with his recivers but when jeff garcia was put in to replace harrington he would constantly get annoyed and frustrated with his wrs
Click to expand...
Jeff Garcia had a rating of 65.1 while Joey had 72.0

more math for you guys :wharf:
 
A.C. said:
Charles Rodgers vs CHRIS CHAMBERS
Roy Williams vs. MARTY BOOKER
Mike Williams vs. DEREK HAGAN

you do the math :wharf:
Click to expand...
Uh... they win 2-1? What exactly is your point?
 
CHAMBERS8484 said:
But you can't dispute the fact that Joey played terribly. That's not to say that it was all his fault, but he showed very little to make me believe he could ever be a starting NFL quarterback. Thank god we have Daunte whom on the other hand has shown all it takes to be a great NFL QB. I hope Joey is a decent backup for us, but Nick Saban knows he is just a short term solution to a short term problem. If Daunte ever goes down, at least we have an experienced backup instead of throwing Cleo out there to the wolves.
Click to expand...
not only that, but you got to look at the
O-Line and the management...
 
well, i dont know about mike williams/charles rogers, but i truely believe Roy Williams would be a top 10 WR with a good QB. Lions locker room had alot of problems last year, so the jury is still out on mike williams. As for Charles Rogers, he actually looked pretty good before he broke his collarbone......twice
 
pwn3dyo said:
well, i dont know about mike williams/charles rogers, but i truely believe Roy Williams would be a top 10 WR with a good QB. Lions locker room had alot of problems last year, so the jury is still out on mike williams. As for Charles Rogers, he actually looked pretty good before he broke his collarbone......twice
Click to expand...


Roy Williams is going to be great. Williams from USC Im not totally sure about yet and Charles Rogers may be out of DEtroit this year if not already. But the bottom line on DEtroit is management and they have always had a management problem. They are like the new Cincinnatti Bungals.
 
Charles Rogers is ALWAYS hurt. Mike Williams got shifted to TE. The O-Line was crap. And NO running game.
 
WitheringPlant said:
Uh... they win 2-1? What exactly is your point?
Click to expand...
Which two do they win? Chambers and Booker have both been to the Pro Bowl. That leaves M. Williams with one year of NFL experience versus Hagan who has yet to play a NFL game.
 
rob banks said:
ok... all i hear is he had 3 recievers that were 1st round picks and still couldn't win games... ok here's the question... who says the 3 recievers are so great??.. they haven't showed me anything and none of them have made the pro bowl... just because your a 1st round pick doesn't mean you will be a great player... i know rodgers has had a tough career with the injuries and roy williams shows talent.. but they still aren't great players yet... was it joey's fault?? maybe.. maybe not.



www.myspace.com/jonesforme
Click to expand...


Detroit had many more problems than WR. That was just one of them. They have no OL and as bad as their offense seemed at times, the D, overall was even worse. The biggest problem was that they have and continue to be a poor FO/management staff. This is where they lack, not necessarily with talent on the field. Hopefully, the new regime will bring more stability to the organization, but you can't look at Detroit's situation and point at one player, or position of players and say "They are the reason we are bad"....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom