HERALD: Answers to 2 Questions Will determine the Dolphins’ Playoff Fate | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

HERALD: Answers to 2 Questions Will determine the Dolphins’ Playoff Fate

Perfect72

It's Only Happened ONCE!
Joined
May 18, 2004
Messages
1,448
Reaction score
665
Location
Florida
...Folks, the Miami Dolphins in the playoffs is not about what happened against the Patriots in the regular-season finale. This postseason, starting with the coming game at Pittsburgh, is about answering two fundamental and important questions:

Is quarterback Ryan Tannehill going to play?

Can the Dolphins’ defense stop anybody?

And this is where I get to deliver news Dolphins fans will think is wonderful because the answer to both questions may be yes.

(That is admittedly the optimistic view because the answer to both questions might also end up being a disappointing no. Only time will tell. But my point is, there is room for hope. Nothing is absolutely being ruled out at this early stage in what will surely be a weeklong process).

So let’s handle one issue at a time. Let’s talk Tannehill first.

You know he’s missed the past three starts and the Dolphins finished 2-1 in that span with Matt Moore at quarterback. Moore, it must be said, has done exemplary work in place of his friend. After his two-touchown performance Sunday, Moore finished the regular season with eight touchdowns and three interceptions and his 105.6 quarterback rating in limited action is actually better than Tannehill’s 93.5.

But don’t be fooled. Tannehill is the superior player when healthy and the Dolphins definitely want him playing against the Steelers if he’s healthy enough. So the process is expected to begin Monday when head coach Adam Gase talks to doctors about the possibility Tannehill can begin to practice.

There is good news even in Gase’s caution. The Dolphins expect Tannehill to practice at least on some level this week. Depending on what happens in those practices, Gase will get an early indication where he’s going with the decision to play Tannehill or not.

If Tannehill looks tentative or seems worried about having players around his legs, the answer will be apparent that he isn’t ready to play. If, however, Tannehill shows he can move around and isn’t tentative in practice, then Gase will have another hill to climb as he decides Tannehill’s fate.

None of this a definitive yes that Tannehill is playing. But neither is it a definitive no that he isn’t.

The decision is pending what happens in practice and the possibility of something good happening will surely be a lift to the team this week.

Then there’s the other issue about the Miami defense. It seems broken.

Dolphins defenders gave up 35 points against New England which was only slightly worse than the 31 points and 600 yards they allowed Buffalo the week before.
It’s not that defensive coordinator Vance Joseph doesn’t know what he’s doing or players are making mistakes. It’s simply that injuries have trimmed the talent level on this unit to the point it’s not playoff worthy anymore.
The two starting safeties Sunday -- Michael Thomas and Bacarri Rambo -- are good players but mostly as backups. And as bad as things are at safety without starters Reshad Jones and Isa Abdul-Quddus, they are worse at linebacker.

Things were so desperate Sunday the Dolphins played Mike Hull, an undrafted free agent with only one start to his credit, at weak side linebacker for a couple of series. And Hull is a middle linebacker who has never played outside.

Yet, the Dolphins have some hope the defense will get better because cornerback Byron Maxwell, out most of the past three weeks with an ankle injury, will be ready to start against Pittsburgh.
And linebacker Jelani Jenkins, who has missed three of the past four games and played only a handful of plays in the game he didn’t miss, could be sufficiently recovered from his knee injury as to let him play against the Steelers.

It will be close on Jenkins. Normally his injury takes as much as six weeks to heal. But he’s shown in his career he’s one tough man who can play even when he’s dragging a limb. And this is the playoffs we’re talking about so I’m assuming Jenkins will try to do the superhuman thing and be in the lineup at Pittsburgh.

Another reason I believe the Dolphins have a chance to contain the Steelers whereas they showed no ability to stop anyone the past few weeks?

The quarterback they’re playing is exactly the kind of quarterback they can play well against.

This defense has proven it struggles against mobile quarterbacks. Tyrod Taylor and Colin Kaepernick baffled Miami with their ability to either pass or run.


More at LINK: http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/s...ro/article124099764.html#emlnl=Dolphins_Extra

Seems like the WILL and CULTURE is there, just with all the INJURIES, that the talent just isn't there. It's easy to say NEXT MAN UP!; but it's a lot more difficult to actually DO in the modern NFL salary cap era when the backups are mostly really good special teamers. Is it unrealistic to expect them to be prepared and their replacements for ST are signed off the PS or the street to expect no let down in ST performance? I believe everyone is doing their level best with what's available; but it may not be enough for the playoffs. Still optimistic. It's the playoffs after all and ANYTHING can happen in the playoff's.

Your thoughts? :ponder:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Wrong. The 2 questions to ask are, can the o-line open holrs for ajayi all game long, and is Byron Maxwell gonna play? Not downplaying RTs importance, just sating that the run game and slowing down brown and bell are the keys. I'm worried about brown if Maxwell cant play.,
 
Last game Maxwell shut down Brown. If he can take away Brown again it will go a long way
 
In regards to the defense, CB isn't exaclty the problem so even if Maxwell plays not sure how much that helps, a healthy Jenkins which seems unliley would help not a half injured one unfortunately.

Were going to need to score in offense, big game from Ajayi and limit turnovers and mistakes.
 
Last game Maxwell shut down Brown. If he can take away Brown again it will go a long way

This run D couldn't stop Gillislee . God help them v Bell
 
If Maxwell plays, who sits?

Howard and Lippett are playing well. Unless we move one of them to slot corner or FS, which none are suited for, I dont see his return as a key upgrade to our defense.

I'm more interested in IAQ or Jenkins getting back in there, safety and linebacker are really the issues we have atm.

A healthy RT would be a nice addition to the offense, but really, this all comes down to the run game. If we cant run the ball we are in for a long day.
 
If Maxwell plays, who sits?

Howard and Lippett are playing well. Unless we move one of them to slot corner or FS, which none are suited for, I dont see his return as a key upgrade to our defense.

I'm more interested in IAQ or Jenkins getting back in there, safety and linebacker are really the issues we have atm.

A healthy RT would be a nice addition to the offense, but really, this all comes down to the run game. If we cant run the ball we are in for a long day.

IAQ is on IR.
 
Wrong. The 2 questions to ask are, can the o-line open holrs for ajayi all game long, and is Byron Maxwell gonna play? Not downplaying RTs importance, just sating that the run game and slowing down brown and bell are the keys. I'm worried about brown if Maxwell cant play.,

No...he is more right than you are.
 
We beat Pittsburgh this year and last time Ryan played in Pitt in the snow we won and Ryan played well. So you have to wonder why we're such heavy underdogs even if Ryan plays.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
We beat Pittsburgh this year and last time Ryan played in Pitt in the snow we won and Ryan played well. So you have to wonder why we're such heavy underdogs even if Ryan plays.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I think its fair to say that the nfl wants pittsburgh to advance so not only are we gonna have to beat the steelers but its very likely that we are gonna have to beat tbe officiating as well
 
Ryan Tannehill returned to practice. Tannehill was running the scout team today. He has been ruled out for Sunday but could be available a week from now if/when Miami advances.

It’s not looking good for Byron Maxwell who is listed as doubtful with an ankle injury.

Some are questioning his absence after he was close to returning last week against the Patriots.

With Maxwell likely out, for now, the Dolphins will go with Xavien Howard, Bobby McCain, and Tony Lippett as the primary corners.

LINK: http://phinphanatic.com/2017/01/06/miami-dolphins-cut-jason-jones-injury-updates/
 
Back
Top Bottom