HERALD: NFL’s final 4 invites us to wonder if Dolphins’ Tannehill is close to GREAT | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

HERALD: NFL’s final 4 invites us to wonder if Dolphins’ Tannehill is close to GREAT

Perfect72

It's Only Happened ONCE!
Joined
May 18, 2004
Messages
1,451
Reaction score
666
Location
Florida
What the NFL’s four surviving teams still in the Super Bowl tournament have in common is about as subtle as a slap in the face. It is a reminder more than a revelation, and it should be sobering to Miami Dolphins fans trying to figure out, after the franchise’s first playoff season since 2008, how near or far their team still is from playing into February.

Great quarterbacking.
[FONT=&quot][/FONT]
That is the difference that gets you there most assuredly, most directly. It is the ultimate answer and solution. It has the ability to overcome deficiencies elsewhere on your roster. It has the power to lift and carry cities and teams.

Not pretty solid quarterbacking. Not maybe-good-enough quarterbacking.

Great quarterbacking.

Pittsburgh at New England and Green Bay at Atlanta are this Sunday’s AFC and NFC Championship Games mostly because of Ben Roethlisberger, Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers and Matt Ryan.

But what’s compelling about this final four starts with the men taking the snaps and in charge. With Brady, the all-time great who seeks to raise the Vince Lombardi trophy as a metaphorical middle finger to the NFL for (he believes) wrongly suspending him four games over Deflategate. With the swaggering gunslingers Roethlisberger and Rodgers. And with Ryan, having one of the greatest individual seasons ever to lead the league’s highest-scoring team.[FONT=&quot]
[/FONT]

All four made the Pro Bowl. Brady, holder of every significant postseason passing record, is a certain first-ballot Hall of Famer and so is Rodgers, of the highest career passer rating ever. Big Ben, two-time champion, is on a likely path to Canton. Can’t say that yet of Ryan, although the season MVP award he should be getting and the Super Bowl ring he might could invite him into that conversation.

These four averaged 4,186 passing yards, 34 touchdowns and a 107.2 rating this season. No final-four teams’ quarterbacks have ever had composite averages that high in all three major categories. By measure of career résumés or season dominance, this is the most pedigreed quarterback final-foursome we have ever had playing to reach the Super Bowl.

This foursome personifies an NFL air-first era that soars on unabated, and it invites every franchise that didn’t get this far, including Miami, to wonder and assess if it is good enough at the most important position — or great enough in other areas to make that matter less.


More at LINK: http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/spt-columns-blogs/greg-cote/article126862349.html

Your thoughts? :ponder:
 
I'm hoping he can keep improving and rooting like hell that he will get there, I started giving up on him last year but now I'm kind of hoping it was more coaching. Obviously don't ever see him getting to Brady status, but maybe he can get close to the other three
 
I'm not sure why Rothlesberger is in that category. He sucked against us and couldn't get his team in the endzone against KC.
 
That kid will have a year in year out under gase qbr of 100 plus here shortly and people will still doubt

remains the bar none most underappreciated qb in football
 
He wasn't even the best QB on our roster. Miami could only beat bottom of he barrel teams when Tannehill played unless Ajayi was rushing for 200+ yards....Cleveland, SF, Rams, Jets, Chargers, Bills, Cards all losing records. The 7 teams Miami beat in which Tannehill started and finished had a combined record of 35 - 77 (17 - 63 if you took out the games Ajayi rushed for over 200 yards)

Moore and Miami's offense outperformed Tannehill and Miami's offense in every significant category with the exception of completion % without the benefit of Moore going up against 5 of the NFL's 7 worst teams in football last year.

The one good characteristic that applied to Tannehill which was durable no longer applies. Tannehill = OVERRATED
 
He wasn't even the best QB on our roster. Miami could only beat bottom of he barrel teams when Tannehill played unless Ajayi was rushing for 200+ yards....Cleveland, SF, Rams, Jets, Chargers, Bills, Cards all losing records. The 7 teams Miami beat in which Tannehill started and finished had a combined record of 35 - 77 (17 - 63 if you took out the games Ajayi rushed for over 200 yards)

Moore and Miami's offense outperformed Tannehill and Miami's offense in every significant category with the exception of completion % without the benefit of Moore going up against 5 of the NFL's 7 worst teams in football last year.

The one good characteristic that applied to Tannehill which was durable no longer applies. Tannehill = OVERRATED

Barring injury, would you be willing to place a very large bet on which QB on our roster starts next year? You seem very sure of your position. I expect you are confident in Gase's ability to decide who will help him win. It seems like a good way to test your take on the brewing QB controversy...
 
TH is not a Great QB and don't think he ever will be. He cannot carry the team. He's a QB that needs a complimentary running game and good to great defense to win a Super Bowl.
 
He wasn't even the best QB on our roster. Miami could only beat bottom of he barrel teams when Tannehill played unless Ajayi was rushing for 200+ yards....Cleveland, SF, Rams, Jets, Chargers, Bills, Cards all losing records. The 7 teams Miami beat in which Tannehill started and finished had a combined record of 35 - 77 (17 - 63 if you took out the games Ajayi rushed for over 200 yards)

Moore and Miami's offense outperformed Tannehill and Miami's offense in every significant category with the exception of completion % without the benefit of Moore going up against 5 of the NFL's 7 worst teams in football last year.

The one good characteristic that applied to Tannehill which was durable no longer applies. Tannehill = OVERRATED
baby-eating-wtf-reaction-what-did-you-say-1403738381g.gif
 
Barring injury, would you be willing to place a very large bet on which QB on our roster starts next year? You seem very sure of your position. I expect you are confident in Gase's ability to decide who will help him win. It seems like a good way to test your take on the brewing QB controversy...
we should be glad we got both...
 
TH is not a Great QB and don't think he ever will be. He cannot carry the team. He's a QB that needs a complimentary running game and good to great defense to win a Super Bowl.

OK, so he's not Aaron Rodgers. That insight was . . . useless.

---------- Post added at 11:04 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:02 PM ----------

Barring injury, would you be willing to place a very large bet on which QB on our roster starts next year? You seem very sure of your position. I expect you are confident in Gase's ability to decide who will help him win. It seems like a good way to test your take on the brewing QB controversy...

we should be glad we got both...

*Re-posted b/c I can't stand the constant quote errors. Nothing more.
 
Need to get rid of players like Pouncey and Albert and replace them with durable lineman that can actually play every game like Atlanta's line so tannehill can take the next step towards elite.
 
Barring injury, would you be willing to place a very large bet on which QB on our roster starts next year? You seem very sure of your position. I expect you are confident in Gase's ability to decide who will help him win. It seems like a good way to test your take on the brewing QB controversy...
we should be glad we got both...

Im very happy to have a solid back up in Moore that can come in and play pretty well if needed...without a doubt. I'm even happier that Tannehill is supposed to be back fully healthy to start next year, with a year under his belt in Gase's system and the confidence of his coach and locker room that he can get the job done. After the post Marino debacle, I'm practically giddy that we have the QB unit we have...
 
For what it's worth...if there were no numbers or names on the jerseys, there's no way that the Pitt QB's performance in the playoffs thus far would be called great...
 
He wasn't even the best QB on our roster. Miami could only beat bottom of he barrel teams when Tannehill played unless Ajayi was rushing for 200+ yards....Cleveland, SF, Rams, Jets, Chargers, Bills, Cards all losing records. The 7 teams Miami beat in which Tannehill started and finished had a combined record of 35 - 77 (17 - 63 if you took out the games Ajayi rushed for over 200 yards)

Moore and Miami's offense outperformed Tannehill and Miami's offense in every significant category with the exception of completion % without the benefit of Moore going up against 5 of the NFL's 7 worst teams in football last year.

The one good characteristic that applied to Tannehill which was durable no longer applies. Tannehill = OVERRATED

:lol: gtfoh
 
Tannehill is a GOOD QB. He is not a GREAT QB. There's a big difference. If you can find someone who you think is an upgrade to Tannehill then you go after him.
 
Back
Top Bottom