How do Vontae and Sean compare to other corners?

[nosleep]

From profootballfocus,

Overall rating from this season:
(includes passes defended, tackling)
(higher is better)

28.5 = Darelle Revis
...
...
2.9 = Nnamdi Asomugha
2.3 = Vontae ***Round 1 Pick 25
2.0 = Will Allen
...
-0.5 = Sean Smith ***Round 2 Pick 61
...
-2.5 = Lito Sheppard
-2.7 = Nate Jones
...
-4.3 = Darius Butler ***Round 2 Pick 41
...
-8.1 = Malcom Jenkins ***Round 1 Pick 14
-8.3 = Andre Goodman


**Edited to add rookies and place picked

 

[NBP81]

profootball focus is based in NY I hope...

 

[Dolphin Dave]

I think that a better comparison would be to see how they did compared to all the other rookies in their class. Can they be broken down that way?

 

[NBP81]

of course it can... do you have time...?

 

[Breed]

From profootballfocus,

Overall rating from this season:
(includes passes defended, tackling)
(higher is better)

28.5 = Darelle Revis
...
...
2.9 = Nnamdi Asomugha
2.3 = Vontae
2.0 = Will Allen
...
-0.5 = Sean Smith
...
-2.5 = Lito Sheppard
-2.7 = Nate Jones
...
-8.1 = Malcom Jenkins
-8.3 = Andre Goodman

Those numbers would improve drmatically with an effective pass rush and competent S play.

 

[nosleep]

Well, Malcom Jenkins is included in there. He was the only other CB selected in the first round.

 

[nosleep]

Ok, first post edited to include other rookies and spot picked.

 

[miamiron]

From profootballfocus,

Overall rating from this season:
(includes passes defended, tackling)
(higher is better)

28.5 = Darelle Revis
...
...
2.9 = Nnamdi Asomugha
2.3 = Vontae ***Round 1 Pick 25
2.0 = Will Allen
...
-0.5 = Sean Smith ***Round 2 Pick 61
...
-2.5 = Lito Sheppard
-2.7 = Nate Jones
...
-4.3 = Darius Butler ***Round 2 Pick 41
...
-8.1 = Malcom Jenkins ***Round 1 Pick 14
-8.3 = Andre Goodman


**Edited to add rookies and place picked

You might want to give a broader picture than just tackles and passes defended

How about touch downs allowed?
How about total yards allowed?
How about average yards per reception?
How about missed tackles?
How about interceptions?
How about forced fumbles?
How about completion percent against?
How about qb rating against?
How about sacks?
How about qb hits?
How about qb pressures?

It takes more than tackles and passes defended to judge the season a corner has had

 

[nosleep]

You might want to give a broader picture than just tackles and passes defended

It takes more than tackles and passes defended to judge the season a corner has had

Obviously...

I had some spare time today to look up a few stats, and that's what I posted. If I wanted to write a novel breakdown of everyone's stats, that's what I would've done. Like, I said, I posted the overall stats because frankly there's too much information to sift through. If you want that information, be my guest and post it.

 

[67Stang]

I compare Davis to Champ Bailey and Smith to Gumby.

 

[Mulverizer19]

Those numbers would improve drmatically with an effective pass rush and competent S play.

Effective pass rush? Aren't we 2nd in the league in sacks?

 

[next-year]

profootball focus is based in NY I hope...

i hate the jets as much as anyone on this forum

but Revis is a monster. plain an simple.

 

[Breed]

Effective pass rush? Aren't we 2nd in the league in sacks?

I'd be more interested in knowing the number of QB pressures, QB hits, and tackles for loss relative to the league average.

 

[Kowalski550]

Effective pass rush? Aren't we 2nd in the league in sacks?

5th

2nd in the AFC.

Since none of our linebackers can cover anyone or average over 4 tackles a game they better, at least, get sacks.

 

[RockyMtnPhinfan]

They seem to be producing relative to their draft positions, that is good for two rookies. I can't tell ya'll how excited i am to see them develop over a couple of years.