Hypothetical: What would the records of TB and MIA be if they switched rookie RBs?

[SkapePhin]

Do you think there would be any significant difference in the records of either team if Miami had drafted Caddy and TB had drafted Ronnie?

 

[nopony]

No.

 

[Daytona Fin]

maybe if caddy didnt fumble like ronnie did in the buff game we would be 10-6 possible playoffs. other than that i dont think so cause im sure caddy had a crucial fumble sometime during the season.

 

[ih8brady]

Miami's record might be a little worse off because we required our RB to be a recieving option and able to block well which Ronnie did very well. Tampa Bay was a team that needed a RB who could just run, and Caddy fits that bill perfectly.

 

[Daytona Fin]

Do you think there would be any significant difference in the records of either team if Miami had drafted Caddy and TB had drafted Ronnie?

i like the sig but is that a patriots hat or a ufo?

 

[Daytona Fin]

Miami's record might be a little worse off because we required our RB to be a recieving option and able to block well which Ronnie did very well. Tampa Bay was a team that needed a RB who could just run, and Caddy fits that bill perfectly.

that avatar is hilarious :sidelol:

 

[kastofsna120]

cadilac iz da better playe rguys!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[akfinfan]

Tampa would have a better record because they have had the better RB.

 

[Samphin]

Considering Ronnie use dhis body to help save our QB's countless times, I would have to say that our record would probably be a little worse. I can't speak for Caddy's blocking skills, but I doubt they are as complete and polished as Ronnie's.

 

[nopony]

Tampa would have a better record because they have had the better RB.

And you think this because...?

Is it because Caddy got more carries because Ricky Williams isn't on his team?

Is it because Caddy had a third of yard WORSE YPC?

I'm really not seeing why anyone thinks Caddy is better than Ronnie. Even at just the running, he wasn't better. Let alone the A+ job Ronnie did blocking and recieving.

 

[Mrcarciero]

Cadillac is the better running back. The whole country sees this except us. We are in denial.

 

[Bjorn]

Do you think there would be any significant difference in the records of either team if Miami had drafted Caddy and TB had drafted Ronnie?

No I think the only significant change is if we overworked Ronnie like Gruden does with Caddy. They seemed to run him every chance they had.

 

[nopony]

Cadillac is the better running back. The whole country sees this except us. We are in denial.

See, I gave you reasons and stats to prove that wasn't true. If you'd like back up your opinion, cool. If not, then please don't be offended I don't take your word for it.

I'll take a blocking, recieving, 4.4 YPC running back over a non-blocking, poor recieiving, 4.1 YPC running back every day of the week.

 

[houtz]

It would not be any different. Caddy would still be sharing carries with Ricky Williams. He might've had a few more yards because he might not've got injured like Ronnie Brown did but other than that there is no way Caddy would've made any big difference if any at all.

 

[FinNasty]

Do you think there would be any significant difference in the records of either team if Miami had drafted Caddy and TB had drafted Ronnie?

not at all... if anything... TB's might have been better. Ronnie would probably have been healthy when they played SF... giving them atleast 1 extra W...