i belive a healthy pep .... | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

i belive a healthy pep ....

A

alan huber

Starter
Joined
Mar 11, 2006
Messages
406
Reaction score
1
Location
mexico city
i belive that a healthy cullpeper would be better then a healthy brees , because of our sistem , remeber we are still using linehan sistem and we all know that pep had great years in that sistem
 
I would take either. Culpepper or Bree in my opinion would succeed in our SYSTEM.
 
i agree that pep would be better and is better and has a better chance of recovering fully from his injury

HOWEVER

like i said in another post

i dont care who it is because SABAN will get who he thinks is best for us
 
stoody24 said:
i agree that pep would be better and is better and has a better chance of recovering fully from his injury

HOWEVER

like i said in another post

i dont care who it is because SABAN will get who he thinks is best for us
Click to expand...


i still like how you think bro :sidelol:
 
with Culpeppers injury he would prolly give us 3 quality years
with Brees injury he would give us 5 quality years
 
Finsletmedown said:
with Culpeppers injury he would prolly give us 3 quality years
with Brees injury he would give us 5 quality years
Click to expand...
how do you figure bro

i think i have to disagree
once peps knee is healed, it will be stronger than ever

anyways no one knows how many healthy years are ahead of either player except my lord and savior Jesus Christ
 
Finsletmedown said:
with Culpeppers injury he would prolly give us 3 quality years
with Brees injury he would give us 5 quality years
Click to expand...

I think it is the other way around... especially for Culpepper. As long as he can throw, he will be good. I think there is a shorter shelf-life on Brees' shoulder...
 
stoody24 said:
how do you figure bro

i think i have to disagree
once peps knee is healed, it will be stronger than ever

anyways no one knows how many healthy years are ahead of either player except my lord and savior Jesus Christ
Click to expand...
knee gets stronger?? even when you tear all the ligaments holding your knee in place?

based off age and the seriousness of the injury
 
Given equal health of both, Culpepper would be a better fit for our system. But Brees is a bit younger and less turnover prone, and could probably run just as effective an offense, so I give the edge to him.
 
Finsletmedown said:
knee gets stronger?? even when you tear all the ligaments holding your knee in place?

based off age and the seriousness of the injury
Click to expand...


yeah thats what happend to Lee Evans, he messed up his knee but it came back stronger through rehab

Knees tend to get stronger after fully healed although not in all cases, while shoulders get weaker
 
Alex22 said:
yeah thats what happend to Lee Evans, he messed up his knee but it came back stronger through rehab

Knees tend to get stronger after fully healed although not in all cases, while shoulders get weaker
Click to expand...

ahhh:wink:
 
Finsletmedown said:
age
Click to expand...
still have to disagree

some people can last a lot longer than others
depends on how each players bady reacts to hits and injuries as they age

ex. pennington may be on the downside of his career (same injury as brees i think)

anyway yes age is a way to look at it but i think you have to factor that with each of their injuries and see that throwing on a bad shoulder and throwing on a bad knee are completely different to just have 2 yrs difference in your opinion

just my thought
 
No doubt. A healthy Pep is a top 5, IMO top 4, QB.
Im not gonna be picky over wheter we get brees or Pep though. Both are great.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom