I was just listening to WQAM, they said a writer up north heard Cleveland offered Braland Edwards to the Phins for Camarillo a 3rd and a 5th. I say its probably bogus because we would have jumped all over that trade. Anyone heard of this or think it is true????
I wonder if this is true???
- Thread starter JCfinfan
- Start date
wonderl33t
Club Member
Sounds feasible since that's about what the Jets gave for him
NJPhinFan21
Scout Team
could be possible.
ArmyFin7
U cry about the $$$, we do the dirtywork
Could be true....if it is I for 1 am glad we didn't do it. Henne looked Camarillos way a lot last week, I wouldnt want to give up Hennes fav target and 2 pickes for a bigger Ginn....
arsenal
Beastin'
thank god we didn't... that would have been horrible for us wasting our draft picks
im glad our FO does things the right way building talent, not mortgaging that potential talent on gambles like Edwards... stick to the Steelers philosophy, there is a reason they are one of the best teams in the league every damn year
im glad our FO does things the right way building talent, not mortgaging that potential talent on gambles like Edwards... stick to the Steelers philosophy, there is a reason they are one of the best teams in the league every damn year
The upside might have been worth it (if true) The thing that would have bothered me is that he is in a contract year and the options after playing only 12 regular season games would be to lose him to FA (unless no new coll bargaining agreement is made), franchise tag him and pay way too much, or sign to a long term contract that is probably too much $ as well. I do not like any of those options although his upside can be amazing.
Camarillo catches everything thrown to him.. Edwards does not
utahphinsfan
Club Member
1) Who is this we you refer to?
2) AM Sports talk radio is almost as reliable as stuff found on the 'net.
arsenal
Beastin'
keep this in mind people, a 3rd and a 5th could be Kendall Langford and Donald Thomas...
would anyone in their right mind trade a bust like Braylon Edwards for Kendall Langford and Donald Thomas????
would anyone in their right mind trade a bust like Braylon Edwards for Kendall Langford and Donald Thomas????
I doubt we would even trade Camarillo for Edwards straight up.. I would be pissed if we did.
I think with all the heat building up over Mangini's sweetheart deals, this is just someone in NY or Cleveland's way of spinning it to dilute this spreading impression. Me personally, I'm wondering exactly what Mangini's severance package was from NYJ and how much of it involved under-the-table payments for future preferential deals. To me that's a more likely scenario.
1) Who is this we you refer to?
2) AM Sports talk radio is almost as reliable as stuff found on the 'net.
Sid Rosenburg show. He didnt say it, someone else did. I dont believe it, thats why I asked in my thread title, I wonder if true?? Who knows.
Predaphin
Predator in the Water
Who would you rather have better Camarillo or Stuckey?