If Miami Got #2 back Would Feeley Be OK ? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

If Miami Got #2 back Would Feeley Be OK ?

Sgt.FinFan

Sgt.FinFan

Starter
Joined
Mar 19, 2002
Messages
479
Reaction score
5
Say in the course of a couple of trade downs Miami got
back their #2 from Philly. Would Feeley then get more
slack from people ?
 
Sgt.FinFan said:
Say in the course of a couple of trade downs Miami got
back their #2 from Philly. Would Feeley then get more
slack from people ?
Click to expand...

No QB we ever get will be good enough for some people because they are stuck in the past with Marino and can't move on. Everyone will be compared to Dan and that's why no QB will ever get a fair shake in Miami. Would you want to play here and be held up to that standard? I wouldn't
 
LtDan662002 said:
No QB we ever get will be good enough for some people because they are stuck in the past with Marino and can't move on. Everyone will be compared to Dan and that's why no QB will ever get a fair shake in Miami. Would you want to play here and be held up to that standard? I wouldn't
Click to expand...

Perfect Example: John Elway - Jake the Fake.... He will never lead them to the promise land....

But if AJ Feely becomes a pro bowler and puts up great numbers (ala Manning, Green, etc) it will be easier to forgive....

The chiefs gave up a 1st rounder to the Rams for Green and everyone wanted to cut trINT and shoot him in year one... 3 years later he leads the best offense in the NFL and all is forgiven....

If feely can become a stud I think people will forgive and say how a 2nd rounder was worth a QBOTF - But until then its a bust even if you pick up a 2nd...
 
unless feeley proves himself this year - that will be the only way to justify trading that pick whether we get it back or not - personally i hope he can run our offense - he had some good moments last year - i will always be one that feels we overpayed for that guy when we did
 
LtDan662002 said:
No QB we ever get will be good enough for some people because they are stuck in the past with Marino and can't move on. Everyone will be compared to Dan and that's why no QB will ever get a fair shake in Miami. Would you want to play here and be held up to that standard? I wouldn't
Click to expand...

Not at all. All I want is a guy that can lead a team, make good decisions with the football, and make big plays occasionally. Jay Fiedler, Ray Lucas, and A.J. Feeley don't fit those criteria.
 
I think if Feeley does better this year I will be happy. The team was bad in almost every area last year and Feeley didn't have a good chance to show what he can really do with an adequete Offensive line and decent skill position players. Next years QB class is much more attractive than this years so I will be happy to turn #2 into extra picks and think about a franchise QB next year after looking at Feeley more. GreenMonster
 
GreenMonster said:
I think if Feeley does better this year I will be happy. The team was bad in almost every area last year and Feeley didn't have a good chance to show what he can really do with an adequete Offensive line and decent skill position players. Next years QB class is much more attractive than this years so I will be happy to turn #2 into extra picks and think about a franchise QB next year after looking at Feeley more. GreenMonster
Click to expand...

Next year's QB class could be the worst since 2000...
 
Sgt.FinFan said:
Say in the course of a couple of trade downs Miami got
back their #2 from Philly. Would Feeley then get more
slack from people ?
Click to expand...

HELL NO!

Throwing INT's and INT's returned for TD's is the only thing hes good for!
 
Steve Young did well under Montana's shadow. Ya I know not the same thing.

LtDan662002 said:
No QB we ever get will be good enough for some people because they are stuck in the past with Marino and can't move on. Everyone will be compared to Dan and that's why no QB will ever get a fair shake in Miami. Would you want to play here and be held up to that standard? I wouldn't
Click to expand...
 
LtDan662002 said:
No QB we ever get will be good enough for some people because they are stuck in the past with Marino and can't move on. Everyone will be compared to Dan and that's why no QB will ever get a fair shake in Miami. Would you want to play here and be held up to that standard? I wouldn't
Click to expand...

When comparing a 61 passer rating to Dan Marino, there's plenty of room to get somebody quite a bit better than the 61...
 
FiN.in.RI said:
Will San Diego need to unload Phillip Rivers?
Click to expand...

Their QB situation will resolve itself likely after this season.
 
How could next years QB class be worse than this year. 2 QB's that nobody is sure of and some good 2-3 round guys. Atleast Leinart will be a franchise QB in some GM's opinion. Others like this year will emerge (see Alex Smith).. GreenMonster
 
Ya he threw some pick 6's, but that was LAST YEAR.

WE have a new team this year. Feeley will do better. I for one do not think we WASTED a draft pick. Wanny can't coach a football game. That was Feeley's problem last year.

Shifty187 said:
HELL NO!

Throwing INT's and INT's returned for TD's is the only thing hes good for!
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom