If we get a WR in trade who do we dump?

[Gadsden86]

Ok so lets just say for the sake of saying it. We trade for a WR this week.
That would give us
1.Camarillo
2. Bess
3. Ginn
4. Hartline
5. Turner


I would think we would move one of them as keeping 6 Wr's would be alot as we normaly have 4 active during the game.

Or do we keep them all and have 1 less player at another position active for games and have 5 WR's on gameday.

 

[arsenal]

theres no way we give up on our young guys... we need Ginn as hes our only guy who can stretch the field... and i cant see us getting rid of cam or bess... i say keep 6

 

[Cloudy]

I say keep 6 as well. Can't really justify of getting rid of any of them.

 

[JCfinfan]

The next question is, just say we trade for Bowe and KC wants a draft pick and a WR. Who do we include in the trade???

Bess??? I dunno?? Tough call

 

[Butterfrog 2.0]

IF Miami traded for a WR they would most likely be giving one back in return and more than likely it would be Bess or Camarillo.

 

[truedolfan57]

which will not happen.

 

[Butterfrog 2.0]

For those of you that want to trade for a WR AND keep all of the ones we have.... How many WR's do you really think the Phins plan on playing every week? If Miami traded for Bowe and sent cam or Bess then we still have Bowe, Ginn, Cam/Bess, Hartline, Turner. If you trade for someone like Bowe then he's never coming off the field so someone else is hardly going to see the field anyway.

 

[bpackers13]

If we part with Bess.......I'm going to be pissed

 

[Gadsden86]

Good points guys. So if we did get bowe we would begiving up one of our guys and i think it leens towards bess.

I for one like what we have Bowe or another big name would be nice but our wr's are very young for the most part and have show good flashes. We do need a true #1 but would be giving up a good wr in return.

 

[godolphins1985]

it would be turner

 

[Rhody Phins Fan]

If we part with Bess.......I'm going to be pissed

He is averaging 35 yards per game. I like him but if we need to give him up for Bowe then we shouldn't hesitate.

 

[godolphins1985]

hes not getting thrown to enough, thats ok because when he is thrown to he CATCHES IT. Other than offensive weapons like (R&R, Ginn) Bess is crucial in our offense at converting 1st downs and getting those tough yards, we dont need that same mistake at not retaining a wes welker type player that plays for peanuts.

 

[houtz]

If we part with Bess.......I'm going to be pissed

I want Bowe real bad but this pretty much sums up my feelings on getting rid of Bess.

Camarillo, Roth and a 4th.

Hartline is essentially the same player as Camarillo.

Just do something Miami. I don't want to hear how we tried to do so much after the deadline. Make something happen!

 

[Vaark]

I wouldn't discount the possibility of a trade including either Turner or Hartline although agree that regrettably, Cam would be the one traded. No way the FO is letting Bess go.

 

[BenchFiedler]

I want Bowe real bad but this pretty much sums up my feelings on getting rid of Bess.

Camarillo, Roth and a 4th.

Hartline is essentially the same player as Camarillo.

Just do something Miami. I don't want to hear how we tried to do so much after the deadline. Make something happen!

Its a crazy idea to trade Camarillo. He makes plays after plays and converted some key 3rd downs for us. He is QB friendly and a good option for Chad Henne who will make only his 3rd NFL start.

How about we trade a defensive guy instead of another WR. I would get rid of Crowder...