if you could go back in time and draft Cadillac....

[finsgonewild]

.....if you could go back in time, would you draft cadillac williams instead of ronnie brown?

 

[PhenomenalPhin]

Too early to tell IMO. Yes Cadillac is looking great, but I think we should ask this question maybe once the season over.

 

[JTBRLZ]

No

 

[mor911]

1st, we cannot go back in time people.. get over it. :D 2nd, let the coach do his job.

That is all

 

[ffphin]

Nope!!!! The Bucs have a way better line and Cadilac is getting 28 rushes a game. Not trying to take anything away from Williams but you got to fight for Brown if you truely are a Dolphin fan. I have high expectaions for him when Ricky comes back in the Bucs game. Because I'm going to be there!!!

 

[Static387]

I'm pleased with what we have. Imagine when the Oline starts run blocking.

 

[South Florida]

It doesn't mean anything, really, but with 88 carries he has 1 catch for 0 yards.

No, I wouldn't.

I like our running back. On paper he still grades out as astounding.

Lets wait and see.

 

[Caps]

Why would I want the second best back when Ronnie is there for the taking?

 

[Rufio]

These threads are ridiculous ... for god sake look at the O-line that Ronnie has to work with compared to the O-line that Caddy works with ... Obviously he has to put in his part as well but Ronnie came in late and we don't even have an established line yet! Hey ... if we could go back in time do you think we could draft Tom Brady before the Pats had a chance in the later rounds? Give me a break.

 

[finjim123]

No!!!!!!!!!

 

[ohall]

Not me. I don't buy into this whole idea that Caddy would of had the same success on this team. Just like I think if Marino was drafted by a different team than the Dolphins he may not of had the same type of career as he did here in Miami. Maybe it would have been better, or maybe worse. Who knows?

Ronnie was the only choice. He is bigger and faster. You do not pass up on a HB his size that can run as fast as he does. He is a rare talent. Not saying Caddy is not, but Ronnie had and still has more potential than Caddy does.

 

[finsgonewild]

well im also happy with having ronnie. If we had Cadillac then we couldnt use Ronnie and Ricky together. Ronnie is able to play more positions and be better utilized. If we got Cadillac then Ricky and him would just be splitting carries.

 

[[S][T][O][R][M]]

.....if you could go back in time, would you draft cadillac williams instead of ronnie brown?

NO ... I'm happy with RB.


And if the Tampa Bay Ducks called today for a trade, I'd say go whistle dixie.





The Jills are ... :0wned:

 

[SmokinGunz]

guys you do realize that tampa has a way better Oline than ours, so if Caddy would be here he wouldn't do much and Ronnie would be running all over the place with Tampa, then you guys might be saying " we should've drafted Ronnie" give the Oline some chance to open wholes and block or wait till next year when we have a mch better Oline.


Awesome theme song Mor911 :band:

 

[phinman1]

I would choose the bigger, faster back. The one with better hands, the one who picks up the blitz better and is also a better blocker. The one who would fit in better with Ricky. That means Brown.