If you had to... Keep & Cut | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

If you had to... Keep & Cut

NYFINNER

NYFINNER

Fins are my crack!
Joined
Mar 26, 2005
Messages
366
Reaction score
0
Location
NY
Some say out w/the old & in w/the new. Some say if it's got a broken leg, shoot it. Some like nice prospects & some like past performances. I'm curious to see how many of us think the same! Not going to get into why I feel the way I do about the below, but feel free to if you want.

If you had to pick a player on Defense who couldn't be cut? Taylor
If you had to pick a player on Defense to cut? Seau
If you had to pick a player on Offense who couldn't be cut? Brown
If you had to pick a player on Offense to cut? Boston
 
NYFINNER said:
Some say out w/the old & in w/the new. Some say if it's got a broken leg, shoot it. Some like nice prospects & some like past performances. I'm curious to see how many of us think the same! Not going to get into why I feel the way I do about the below, but feel free to if you want.

If you had to pick a player on Defense who couldn't be cut? Taylor
If you had to pick a player on Defense to cut? Seau
If you had to pick a player on Offense who couldn't be cut? Brown
If you had to pick a player on Offense to cut? Boston
Click to expand...

If you had to pick a player on Defense who couldn't be cut? Jason Taylor
If you had to pick a player on Defense to cut? Reggie Howard
If you had to pick a player on Offense who couldn't be cut? Ronnie Brown
If you had to pick a player on Offense to cut? Stockar McDougle
 
ChambersWI said:
we can't cut McDougle,Seau or Boston. They are all Free Agents :lol:
Click to expand...

I know that, I'm just asking who you think should be gone & at no cost should be cut!!!
 
1)Thomas(Cant replace a heart like zach thomas)
2)Howard(Dont Support him)
3)Brown(Running Back in the making)
4)Boston(All he knows to do is to get hurt and take steroids)
 
NYFINNER said:
I know that, I'm just asking who you think should be gone & at no cost should be cut!!!
Click to expand...

ah ok, in that case.

Crowder (he not only became a good player this year, but he became a great leader as the year went on)

Howard (I can't support him anymore)

Ronnie (has all the tools to be a great RB)

Boston (I give McDougle a break because he did miss most of camp after his brother got shot)
 
Taylor
Whoever sucks enough to play behind Reggie Howard
Brown
Boston
 
NYFINNER said:
Some say out w/the old & in w/the new. Some say if it's got a broken leg, shoot it. Some like nice prospects & some like past performances. I'm curious to see how many of us think the same! Not going to get into why I feel the way I do about the below, but feel free to if you want.

If you had to pick a player on Defense who couldn't be cut? Taylor
If you had to pick a player on Defense to cut? Seau
If you had to pick a player on Offense who couldn't be cut? Brown
If you had to pick a player on Offense to cut? Boston
Click to expand...

1. Carter/ Holliday I like what they did on the line and you no Jt aint going anywhere so i chose them
2. Id cut howard get him the hel outta here he doesnt nothing but cost us games lets try and get back to the days were teams fdeared having to throw on us
3. Obviously Ronnie he isnt going anywhere
4. I have two choices one is frerrote if he really is a 5 mil hit pn the cap next year or another is jeno james he is getting older but he still only 28 he is not dominant and is owed somewhere between 3-5 million hes been solid for us but not if we have to pay him that much plus i think houck likes what he foud in this kid brooks we ended up getting
 
Zack
Howard
Brown
Boston

Ozzy rules!! :rockon: :guitar:
 
Taylor and Thomas, I'm not pickin one!!!!!!!!!
Howard
Chambers
McDougle
 
Player on offense to cut Frerotte so we don't have to wonder anymore

runner up Brian Gilmore damn how u dissapoint me

Player on offense that is uncuttable Chris Chambers, he is a special player just a good QB away from being elite.

Player on defense to cut : Reggie Howard (God does he suck)

Runner up: Junior Seau Great leader but no real need to have him here anymore classy guy though.

Untouchable Defensive player: Three way tie Thomas, Taylor and Crowder
 
dlockz said:
Player on offense to cut Frerotte so we don't have to wonder anymore

runner up Brian Gilmore damn how u dissapoint me

Player on offense that is uncuttable Chris Chambers, he is a special player just a good QB away from being elite.

Player on defense to cut : Reggie Howard (God does he suck)

Runner up: Junior Seau Great leader but no real need to have him here anymore classy guy though.

Untouchable Defensive player: Three way tie Thomas, Taylor and Crowder
Click to expand...

Quite a few people said you got cut HOWARD. I wonder if today changed their minds at all. I said Seau, because he was on the downward spiral, but I'd have to agree that Howards got to go too, and yes even after todays performance.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you had to pick a player on Defense who couldn't be cut?JT and Zach ....srry but we cant lose either of them...
If you had to pick a player on Defense to cut? Seau//alaways hurt...and to be honest with you i really like reggie howard...he makes alot of great plays (safety today and a pick in the redzone but call back because of roughing the passer)and gets ripped off on calls alot alot......and he blocked the kick against the jets.....those are just a couple....
If you had to pick a player on Offense who couldn't be cut?ricky and CC...we obviusly arent gettin rid of brown so i wont even put it....
If you had to pick a player on Offense to cut? MRs.Cleo tells me to cut the LEMON!!!
 
If you had to pick a player on Defense who couldn't be cut? Taylor
If you had to pick a player on Defense to cut? Howard
If you had to pick a player on Offense who couldn't be cut? Brown
If you had to pick a player on Offense to cut? Boston
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom