If you think Tua is playing again this year… | Page 20 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

If you think Tua is playing again this year…

dunegoon said:
If there weren't any errors, why in the hell was the doc fired? Fired for not "suggesting " he not get back on the field ? The very definition of victim of circumstance for both the doc and Tua... does this kid have a hex placed on him or what?
Click to expand...
It's already been stated that the doctor was combatitive in the interview process and did not fully understand his role. Know what was not been said? That he made an error with his diagnosis.

The NFLPA has the right -- by contract with the NFL -- to release any UNC they wish to. They don't need a reason. But at this point, they ONLY information we have received on his release has nothing to do with his actual diagnosis.
 
andyahs said:
Maybe that's his issue,
Click to expand...
Yeah...it's like

"I'll wait until the investigation is done" and then immediately reaches his own conclusions.

And then when it's pointed out that to this point NO medical errors or protocol violations have occurred (which, honestly, if they haven't been found at this point despite interviewing everyone involved, it's not going to happen), he STILL doubles down and says their were errors.
 
Swiss said:
LOL. Quote me where I said "medical errors" occurred. I'll wait here.
Click to expand...
You didn't have to wait long:

"I think you misunderstood the NFLPA's point. They said even if it wasn't a concussion, and it was this back injury that resulted in gross motor instability,, he ALSO should have been out of the game. Either way the consultant acted negligent and was therefore fired."

Sorry, swiss cheese head, tap dance elsewhere.
 
Ryan1973 said:
That doesn't mean that Tua had an actual concussion in that game. You are spinning this false narrative that Tua was concussed in the Bills game and you have no evidence to back that up.
Click to expand...
I am not. You are another person who is not comprehending what I am saying. I have never said I believe he sustained a concussion against Buffalo. I have even questioned why when a boxer or MMA fighter gets staggered in a fight from a hard blow to the head, they don’t instantly stop the fight for fear of a concussion. I don’t believe Tua was concussed in the Buffalo game, but the decision makers and the people weighing in on the situation are acting as if he was. The pressure on the people deciding Tua’s fate is intense and I’m questioning whether those people have the fortitude to make an unbiased decision.
 
brumdog44 said:
You didn't have to wait long:

"I think you misunderstood the NFLPA's point. They said even if it wasn't a concussion, and it was this back injury that resulted in gross motor instability,, he ALSO should have been out of the game. Either way the consultant acted negligent and was therefore fired."

Sorry, swiss cheese head, tap dance elsewhere.
Click to expand...
I said they were negligent based on the fact they made “several mistakes” and were fired. So you were wrong, and I didn't say "medical errors." Thanks for the apology.
 
Dolphann4life said:
It’s simply not happening. Tua has been made a concussion Martyr by the media. Roger Godell is very public opinion driven. My expectation is he will urge the dolphins to sit Tua the rest of the year. This is very unfair to the Dolphins, Tua and our fans. Tua should play when the doctors clear him not the media. We have people calling for Tua’s retirement (LOL). After a concussion with no history of concussion prior! Insanity. Meanwhile players all over the league are passing protocols multiple times (See Tee Higgins) and helping their teams to victories. This is disgusting. Can’t help but feel we’re being singled out. Season is over.
Click to expand...
Leaving Tua out too long has its own problems - he'll be in 3 prob....
 
rickd13 said:
I am not. You are another person who is not comprehending what I am saying. I have never said I believe he sustained a concussion against Buffalo. I have even questioned why when a boxer or MMA fighter gets staggered in a fight from a hard blow to the head, they don’t instantly stop the fight for fear of a concussion. I don’t believe Tua was concussed in the Buffalo game, but the decision makers and the people weighing in on the situation are acting as if he was. The pressure on the people deciding Tua’s fate is intense and I’m questioning whether those people have the fortitude to make an unbiased decision.
Click to expand...
They better make an unbiased decision or they are going to open up a can of worms for players to go after them with lawsuits.
 
Last edited:
He needs Royal Raymond Rife healing technologies plus hyperbaric o2 healing.....in Winterland Fla for free....
 
rickd13 said:
I am not. You are another person who is not comprehending what I am saying. I have never said I believe he sustained a concussion against Buffalo. I have even questioned why when a boxer or MMA fighter gets staggered in a fight from a hard blow to the head, they don’t instantly stop the fight for fear of a concussion. I don’t believe Tua was concussed in the Buffalo game, but the decision makers and the people weighing in on the situation are acting as if he was. The pressure on the people deciding Tua’s fate is intense and I’m questioning whether those people have the fortitude to make an unbiased decision.
Click to expand...
They don't that's definitely more factual then their so called findings for sure.
 
Swiss said:
I said they were negligent based on the fact they made “several mistakes” and were fired. So you were wrong, and I didn't say "medical errors." Thanks for the apology.
Click to expand...
There is a difference between “negligence” and “mistakes.”
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom