I'm sorry for starting another thread about the QB BUT........ | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

I'm sorry for starting another thread about the QB BUT........

NYC#1finsfan

NYC#1finsfan

Active Roster
Joined
May 8, 2005
Messages
5,671
Reaction score
4,956
Location
Brooklyn, NY
In the NFL you need a FRANCHISE type QB if you are going to win in January/February. Tua is a nice QB but he is NOT a Franchise QB. Tier 1 QB's........ Mahomes, Rodgers, Brady, Burrow, Wilson, Herbert then you have tier 2 type franchise QB's, Stafford, Prescott, Allen, Murray, L. Jackson.......We can debate this forever and a lot of you won't agree with me on my tier's, that's fine however the BOTTOM LINE is that regardless of stats, Tua is a Tier 4 type QB like a Baker Mayfield, Hieneke, Goff, etc............To win a Super Bowl ONLY PICK Tier 1 or 2 the Trent Dilfer years are over............
 
NYC#1finsfan said:
In the NFL you need a FRANCHISE type QB if you are going to win in January/February. Tua is a nice QB but he is NOT a Franchise QB. Tier 1 QB's........ Mahomes, Rodgers, Brady, Burrow, Wilson, Herbert then you have tier 2 type franchise QB's, Stafford, Prescott, Allen, Murray, L. Jackson.......We can debate this forever and a lot of you won't agree with me on my tier's, that's fine however the BOTTOM LINE is that regardless of stats, Tua is a Tier 4 type QB like a Baker Mayfield, Hieneke, Goff, etc............To win a Super Bowl ONLY PICK Tier 1 or 2 the Trent Dilfer years are over............
Click to expand...
He played horribly and performances like today definitely put doubt in everyone’s heads. However, I think we need one more year. He has grown significantly from last year. If he can grow again next year then I think we’ve got our guy, because he does flash and he is close. Then if he doesn’t make it definitive with his performance we go into 2023 with 2 first rounders and we can try again.
 
Well, this franchise under this iwnership has proven it will mismanage a QB coming and going. whether it makes a good choice in the draft or not.
 
NYC#1finsfan said:
In the NFL you need a FRANCHISE type QB if you are going to win in January/February. Tua is a nice QB but he is NOT a Franchise QB. Tier 1 QB's........ Mahomes, Rodgers, Brady, Burrow, Wilson, Herbert then you have tier 2 type franchise QB's, Stafford, Prescott, Allen, Murray, L. Jackson.......We can debate this forever and a lot of you won't agree with me on my tier's, that's fine however the BOTTOM LINE is that regardless of stats, Tua is a Tier 4 type QB like a Baker Mayfield, Hieneke, Goff, etc............To win a Super Bowl ONLY PICK Tier 1 or 2 the Trent Dilfer years are over............
Click to expand...
Dude
You don’t win without running game in December and January and bad weather
And that’s that
If you thought Tua was gonna exceed in that weather without a Line, Running game and only one WR then I wanna sell you a bridge
 
EasyRider said:
Dude
You don’t win without running game in December and January and bad weather
And that’s that
If you thought Tua was gonna exceed in that weather without a Line, Running game and only one WR then I wanna sell you a bridge
Click to expand...
Agreed.
 
Kyndig said:
He played horribly and performances like today definitely put doubt in everyone’s heads. However, I think we need one more year. He has grown significantly from last year. If he can grow again next year then I think we’ve got our guy, because he does flash and he is close. Then if he doesn’t make it definitive with his performance we go into 2023 with 2 first rounders and we can try again.
Click to expand...
Mahomes and the Chiefs scored only 3 points against this Titans defense earlier in the year when they was no wind,rain,or cold weather to contend with.

Yet Tua gets all the blame for the game today and it seems to be enough for many to call for getting rid of Tua. Maybe the Chiefs will trade Mahomes to the Dolphins since he was no better against the Titans than Tua was. Some people on here are ridiculous when it comes to judging Tua based on the crap he has surrounding him on offense.
 
NYC#1finsfan said:
In the NFL you need a FRANCHISE type QB if you are going to win in January/February. Tua is a nice QB but he is NOT a Franchise QB. Tier 1 QB's........ Mahomes, Rodgers, Brady, Burrow, Wilson, Herbert then you have tier 2 type franchise QB's, Stafford, Prescott, Allen, Murray, L. Jackson.......We can debate this forever and a lot of you won't agree with me on my tier's, that's fine however the BOTTOM LINE is that regardless of stats, Tua is a Tier 4 type QB like a Baker Mayfield, Hieneke, Goff, etc............To win a Super Bowl ONLY PICK Tier 1 or 2 the Trent Dilfer years are over............
Click to expand...
Dude.....Goff has been in a superbowl and you have him as a 'tier 4'.

And are there no tier 3 guys?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom