In which tier do you place Ryan Tannehill?

[yoge]

Lets be realistic here. I got Tanny in tier 3. Do you all agree or disagree?

[h=2]Tier 1[/h][h=2]T-1. Aaron Rodgers[/h][h=2]T-1. Tom Brady[/h][h=2]3. Andrew Luck[/h][h=2]4. Ben Roethlisberger[/h][h=2]5. Peyton Manning[/h][h=2]6. Drew Brees[/h]
Tier 2

7. Philip Rivers

8. Russell Wilson

9. Tony Romo

10. Joe Flacco

11. Matt Ryan

T-12. Eli Manning

T-12. Matthew Stafford

14. Cam Newton

[h=2]Tier 3[/h][h=2]15. Carson Palmer[/h][h=2]16. Alex Smith[/h][h=2]17. Ryan Tannehill[/h][h=2]T-18. Colin Kaepernick[/h][h=2]T-18. Andy Dalton[/h][h=2]T-20. Derek Carr[/h][h=2]T-20. Jay Cutler[/h][h=2]22. Nick Foles[/h][h=2]T-23. Sam Bradford[/h][h=2]T-23. Teddy Bridgewater[/h]

Tier 4

25. Marcus Mariota

26. Jameis Winston

27. Blake Bortles

28. Robert Griffin III

29. Josh McCown

30. Brian Hoyer

31. Matt Cassel

32. Geno Smith

 

[Daytona Fin]

Luck #3 and Newton #14?

 

[Trucanes99]

Luck #3 and Newton #14?

Remember, lets be realistic here...

 

[Geforce]

Is this based on a player's career or just last season? If you are talking about last season, there is no way you should have Newton and Wilson in the 2nd tier and Palmer in the 3rd tier.


Oh...RGIII should not even be listed on any tier right now.

 

[Sons Of Shula]

IDGAF. This is pointless, it isn't fantasy football.

Give me great coaching with a solid roster and I'll see you in the postseason.

 

[Daytona Fin]

No Kirk Cousins, does RG3 have a team?

 

[xXwarXx]

PFF rated him the 24th this past season which ranks Him right smack in the middle of tier 3 & 4 on this list. I don't agree with this list, but as far as tiers go, that's probably where he belongs until he proves otherwise.

 

[Phinatic8u]

PFF rated him the 24th this past season which ranks Him right smack in the middle of tier 3 & 4 on this list. I don't agree with this list, but as far as tiers go, that's probably where he belongs until he proves otherwise.

He was rated top 10 the prior 2 seasons.

& at the OP having Luck in the top tier. ****ing hilarious.

 

[fininpsl]

Maybe the OP has some QB's in the wrong tiers, but I think it's fair to say that Tannehill belongs in the middle to back of tier 2. Hes not nearly the trainwreck some want to paint him as. And as bad as his O-line and coaching staffs have been ( and EVERYBODY agrees they've been ****ty the whole time he's been here) I think his NFL story is an incomplete one.

 

[xXwarXx]

He was rated top 10 the prior 2 seasons.

I know, that's why I was excited about him until this season happened.

This past season was really ugly man. He looked like a qb who teams had locked down there scouting reports on, and he proceeded to get exposed.

 

[BlueUndertow]

I think overall Tannehill is a top 15 quarterback although last year he took a step back and was probably only top 20

 

[Martel13]

middle of tier 3 now. But that list is crazy. In general middle of tier 3. I know there's coaching/o-line issues but I just have never seen him look like a great QB in college or the pros yet. He's had a few good complete games but tts more in flashes. I think he has a great chance to move up this year though and Im looking forward to seeing him progress this year under Gase.

 

[Phishpunk@WCU]

Newton at 14, Palmer at 15, and Carr at 20 with Peyton at 5 and Kaepernick at 17? where is Cousins and Fitzpatrick?

i would put Tannehill in the same group with Alex Smith, Andy Dalton, Matt Ryan and Matthew Stafford.

 

[ghost_fish]

Black QBs at the bottom of every tier. SMH

 

[tcdrover]

It looks like they have Luck where Russell Wilson should be.

Tannehill looks about right on there.

This is his big year, he needs to start the preseason like the leading man & prove himself.

They can do much better with him if the rest of the team improves,

my concern is, does he look like a PLAYOFF winning QB?

If the star players are hurt or out, will he be able to get it done?

Our division is very tough, this ain't the AFC South or NFC South