Interesting question on Lebatard show..

[vt_dolfan]

Question posed to Boog Sciampi.......

Would the Dolphins be a playoff team with Brady at QB? Or Manning for that matter.

In other words..are we a QB ONLY away from being a playoff team.

Im of the opinion that we are a playoff team with Brady or Manning....but NOT A SUPER BOWL TEAM.

What do you think?

 

[NJFINSFAN1]

I think if Frogs had wings, could they fly?

 

[Canadianfishfan]

Hmm I think some of their teammates help them look better that our QB...

Harrison is better than all our WR.. for is Branch from N.E. they are stacked with playmakers who are more consistent... I would say ... NO.. we dont go to the Playoff with those guys

 

[maindolfan]

After watching the game against Tampa Bay, I am convinced that we are in desperate need of a QB. Ferotte was terrible with the long ball, as usual. We had at least 3 times that players were wide open and he overthrew. He is neither accurate or mobile. It is no wonder that he has been a backup on his many teams.

The O-line has been doing a pretty respectable job protecting him. I would love to see Sage back there. He can't be any worse.

 

[vt_dolfan]

Hmm I think some of their teammates help them look better that our QB...

Harrison is better than all our WR.. for is Branch from N.E. they are stacked with playmakers who are more consistent... I would say ... NO.. we dont go to the Playoff with those guys

Good answer....

remember no wrong or right answer. I think you made some good points!!

 

[jlfin]

Hmm I think some of their teammates help them look better that our QB...

Harrison is better than all our WR.. for is Branch from N.E. they are stacked with playmakers who are more consistent... I would say ... NO.. we dont go to the Playoff with those guys

:shakeno:

 

[BigDogsHunt]

Question posed to Boog Sciampi.......

Would the Dolphins be a playoff team with Brady at QB? Or Manning for that matter.

In other words..are we a QB ONLY away from being a playoff team.

Im of the opinion that we are a playoff team with Brady or Manning....but NOT A SUPER BOWL TEAM.

What do you think?

QB only...no....

give me NE O-Line or IND O-Line and you have a better shot.

P.S. I will let you know the coverage secondary I would like to swap out as well....

 

[vt_dolfan]

I think if Frogs had wings, could they fly?

From a scientific standpoint..they would be able to fly for short distances...like fish.

 

[vt_dolfan]

I will say...with a pro bowl QB some of those long bombs that have been there...would have connected and the scores could easily have been different.

 

[hollywood316]

hell yeah with feeley started we would be in the playoffs

 

[TIDEPHISH]

I think if Frogs had wings, could they fly?

Great point kinda like "if my aunt had di%& she would be my uncle" type thing but the whole point is those are things we dont have so why even ask why !!!! or could we??? does it matter what we could do ? we dont have one of those and wont have one of those for a very long time .....

 

[vt_dolfan]

Great point kinda like "if my aunt had di%& she would be my uncle" type thing but the whole point is those are things we dont have so why even ask why !!!! or could we??? does it matter what we could do ? we dont have one of those and wont have one of those for a very long time .....

Because sports fans subjigate themselves to second guessing and arm chair Quarterbacking all the time. Its kinda like asking..what would you do if you won the lottery. Will it happen? Probably not, but does it stop people from wondering what it might be like to have bottomless pockets?

We deal in hypotheticals all the time?

My question to you is..why do you take the time to post a response to a question you dont like? Seems silly to me.

 

[JJW1339]

If we had Brady at QB with the Colts Defence and NE Offence, we would win the Super Bowl!

 

[ohall]

No his receivers actually catch passes thrown near them. That is not the situation currently in Miami!

 

[PhinsPhan]

Hmm I think some of their teammates help them look better that our QB...

Harrison is better than all our WR.. for is Branch from N.E. they are stacked with playmakers who are more consistent... I would say ... NO.. we dont go to the Playoff with those guys

Are you kidding?

If we had Brady or Manning we would probably be a Superbowl team. If we had an average QB we would be a playoff team. We have the running game, we have the skill position players. We also have a solid defense.