Is Adam Gase Coach of the Year worthy? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Is Adam Gase Coach of the Year worthy?

I just posted this topic in the general NFL forum. I think Jason Garrett wins . Cowboys might go 15-1. If they do hes a lock with a rookie QB. Gase is in consideration though
 
Pump the breaks a little. It's too early to really do this. San Francisco marks the end of the soft part of our schedule. We will likely win that game to go 7-4, but the challenge is the end of the season stretch run against good teams. Cold weather games in New York, Buffalo, Baltimore, and a season ender against the Brady-led (most likely) Patriots. We still have a lot of challenging games ahead. But ... fingers crossed. We can revisit this as our season unfolds more.
 
Gase came in with a team that hasn't made the playoffs in 8 years. So far this season, we still aren't in the playoffs. I like what I've seen so far, but way too early to call him coach of the year
 
We can make the playoffs and he still wouldn't win. I love what he's doing with this team. Would love to see what he could do with a healthy more talented team. Missing Jones and Howard on defense and having only one real starting LB hurts there and our o-line can stay healthy which sucks too. He will have his chances in the next few years.

Ozzy rules!!
 
Would love to see him win it, but baring a complete Cowboys meltdown, Garrett will get it. Phins get no respect from mainstream media, but personally, there's not another coach in the league I'd rather have than Gase.
 
There a lot of candidates this year, he will have to keep this up to be considered.
 
Agree with the sentiment that a finish short of the playoffs would remove his name from consideration. If Miami does make the playoffs, his name deserves mention, but I also agree that it's Garrett's to lose at this point. Dak Prescott is amazing. Without question, he's in a great situation, but this is as good as any rookie season that I've ever seen. He's 3rd in passer rating, 108.6 (behind Brady and Ryan) and YPA, 8.3 (also behind Brady and Ryan). He has a 9:1 TD/INT ratio, and he also has 5 rushing TD's (23 total). He's 2nd in 1st Down %, 41.5 (Matt Ryan, 42.8). I was too young to watch Marino when he was a rookie, but I remember Manning, Big Ben, Andrew Luck, and Russell Wilson as rookies, and, as a rookie, Prescott plays with more poise than any of the QB's in that super-elite group. So, Garrett lucked out, though I don't know his involvement in the Prescott pick, but 10-1 with a rookie QB, a rookie RB and a marginal D is pretty amazing. His offensive staff is top-notch, best in the league.
 
The national media loves the Cowboys too much for them to not give it to Garrett. Although he deserves it too. IJS if Miami wins out, they will still give it to Garrett no matter what unless the Cowboys implode.
 
If you actually look at it objectively Garrett has been coach since 2010, so are we saying he is a much better coach than previous years? I imagine he hasn't improved that much, just a better set of players which under Jerry Jones is surprising. Gase would you be critical of a first 5 games where we were awful, and have improved hugely with improved health on the oline? All in all coach if the year is probably a bit like the pro bowl and a bit of a popularity contest, but if it was a real judgement on how the head coach has managed his duties I would think Gase would be my number 1.
 
j-off-her-doll said:
Agree with the sentiment that a finish short of the playoffs would remove his name from consideration. If Miami does make the playoffs, his name deserves mention, but I also agree that it's Garrett's to lose at this point. Dak Prescott is amazing. Without question, he's in a great situation, but this is as good as any rookie season that I've ever seen. He's 3rd in passer rating, 108.6 (behind Brady and Ryan) and YPA, 8.3 (also behind Brady and Ryan). He has a 9:1 TD/INT ratio, and he also has 5 rushing TD's (23 total). He's 2nd in 1st Down %, 41.5 (Matt Ryan, 42.8). I was too young to watch Marino when he was a rookie, but I remember Manning, Big Ben, Andrew Luck, and Russell Wilson as rookies, and, as a rookie, Prescott plays with more poise than any of the QB's in that super-elite group. So, Garrett lucked out, though I don't know his involvement in the Prescott pick, but 10-1 with a rookie QB, a rookie RB and a marginal D is pretty amazing. His offensive staff is top-notch, best in the league.
Click to expand...

No mention of the league's best offensive line by a length of the Amazon river. :idk:

That line plays an enormous factor in the the success that the Dallas offense has experienced.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom