Going from 11-5 to 7-6 does not deserve COY. Yes, we have had injuries, but Henne should be playing instead of Pennington. The only real injury anyone is going to take into account is Ronnie. Ferg is really old.....and Cobbs is a third down back whose play is not measured in stats.
Then you look at losing a 24-3 lead to the Saints and blowing a 45 minute time of possession in the Colts game. Toss in some questionable game management decisions and horrible 4th quarter play.
The only teams we have beat with winning records are a split with the Pats, a Jets sweep (Woot!) and the Jax game where we almost let a dominating performance turn into a loss. The Jets and Jax both will probably not end up over .500.
I like Sparano but this is not coach of the year stuff.