J-Off's 2025 Top 100 | Page 2 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

J-Off's 2025 Top 100

Great job as always! Appreciate all your work on the draft, along with dolfan91 and others.

Hard to believe we have finally arrived on draft day!
 
Last edited:
Kebo said:
Overall I like your list. I just strongly believe in Mykel Williams’ future. Cheers!
Click to expand...

I wish I could get there with his pass rush, because he's an ideal complement to Chop otherwise. I'll say that if Miami drafts him, your faith in his game will make me feel better about the pick, and independent of that, I obv have him ranked higher than Barron, Banks, or Grant.
 
j-off-her-doll said:
To me, it's all about payoff. His legs give him and your offense a floor, but with time to develop, which he does need, his ceiling is that of a #1 overall pick. His character is reported to be A+, so I do think he will develop. How much? That remains to be seen and why I have him Top 10 instead of Top 10.

Appreciate you 🥂
Click to expand...

Not that high on Milroe but these are all very good and fair points. Love your rankings. Unlike many others, can tell you put the work in and don’t rely on general consensus. Always enjoy the read.

Enjoy tonight brother. Appreciate all the work you’ve put in. Definitely have some guys on my radar that weren’t prior to some of your posts.
 
j-off-her-doll said:
To me, it's all about payoff. His legs give him and your offense a floor, but with time to develop, which he does need, his ceiling is that of a #1 overall pick. His character is reported to be A+, so I do think he will develop. How much? That remains to be seen and why I have him Top 10 instead of Top 10.

Appreciate you 🥂
Click to expand...

I think most of his appeal is his upside and potential rather than what he is. A good project with high upside. A poor man's Jalen Hurts with probably better physical ability at the
same point ls in their careers.

The question mark is the arm talent to me. Was Alabama a shadow of what they were or was he a large part of it?
 
BennySwella said:
I think most of his appeal is his upside and potential rather than what he is. A good project with high upside. A poor man's Jalen Hurts with probably better physical ability at the
same point ls in their careers.

The question mark is the arm talent to me. Was Alabama a shadow of what they were or was he a large part of it?
Click to expand...

He has a bazooka, and he's way more athletic than Hurts ever was, but Hurts had a lot more experience coming out, and that's important, because young QB's get short leashes. Experience combined with his strengths and athleticism were major selling points for Hurts. I had him Top 20, when most people thought he was a major reach in the 2nd.

I think Milroe can approximate his success, with the ceiling to be significantly better. It will just take him longer.
 
Michael Scott said:
Not that high on Milroe but these are all very good and fair points. Love your rankings. Unlike many others, can tell you put the work in and don’t rely on general consensus. Always enjoy the read.

Enjoy tonight brother. Appreciate all the work you’ve put in. Definitely have some guys on my radar that weren’t prior to some of your posts.
Click to expand...

Appreciate you 🥂🐬 hope you have a great Draft Night, too 🥳🥂
 
j-off-her-doll said:
To me, it's all about payoff. His legs give him and your offense a floor, but with time to develop, which he does need, his ceiling is that of a #1 overall pick. His character is reported to be A+, so I do think he will develop. How much? That remains to be seen and why I have him Top 10 instead of Top 10.

Appreciate you 🥂
Click to expand...
Develop what? He is terrible. Our playmakers were going to transfer out if he stayed, but that’s supposed to be better
In the league? Respectfully the people who have this guy ranked high show they havnt see all his reps. 4th rounder at best but still can’t be relied on as a backup qb, so are teams going to carry 3 qbs to use his legs?
 
BennySwella said:
I think most of his appeal is his upside and potential rather than what he is. A good project with high upside. A poor man's Jalen Hurts with probably better physical ability at the
same point ls in their careers.

The question mark is the arm talent to me. Was Alabama a shadow of what they were or was he a large part of it?
Click to expand...
He was a LARGE part of the failure.
 
Kebo said:
Grant at 75 has to be disappointing for you.
Click to expand...

Definitely not what I wanted 😅 but I don't get too down, because I could be wrong, and even if I'm not, there are too many other things to enjoy. It's self-defeating to focus on negatives.

The Pearce Jr trade-up was wild as hell. Atlanta must have true Top 10 grades on Walker and Pearce Jr - only way you can justify what they did. I can't get there with Walker, but I do obv like him. Pearce Jr, to me, is a Top 10 talent with no squinting required. They better be right about Penix, but they essentially traded a non-Top 40 2nd, a 2026 1st, and a Day 3 pick for a 2025 1st and a 2025 3rd. For people lower on Pearce Jr, the trade is horrific, and I saw a lot of people say as much. For people, like me, who see Pearce Jr as having the talent to be an All Pro pass rusher, and especially considering Atlanta's need at pass rusher, it's justifiable - so long as Penix is good enough to help you win the division or at least make the playoffs. If you go into 2026 unsure of Penix, and that 2026 pick is Top 15, then you're in trouble. The Penix aspect is the part that gives me pause.
 
I live in Atlanta and the fans are really happy. I think it was an awesome day for the Falcons. Walker and Pearce are going to hunt QBs.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom