Jay Fiedler or Chad Pennington

[CCMiamiDolphins]

Something diffrent. I did the "Whose the better #86 Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker" thread like a year ago. So lets do this, Jay Fiedler or Chad Pennington, who has the stronger arm? And better accuarcy? Who would you want in the huddle?

 

[mantooth]

Neither :d-day:

 

[NCPhinatic]

That's like comparing one pile of crap to another pile of crap. Only difference is the size of the pile.

 

[#1dolphinsfan]

Something diffrent. I did the "Whose the better #86 Orande Gadsden or Marty Booker" thread like a year ago. So lets do this, Jay Fiedler or Chad Pennington, who has the stronger arm? And better accuarcy? Who would you want in the huddle?

Jay Fiedler has the stronger arm, and Chad Pennington has the best Accuarcy because he does little short passes

 

[GoonBoss]

I'll play. Jay Fiedler. I don't hate Pennington, it's just that I have seen a sore lacking of heart on this team and, I know that Jay badly wants to win. I still remember the Raiders game.....Man, I was pumped after that win.

 

[Stefins]

Jay......

 

[Charlie Brown]

Fielder, he made plays when he had to, it was ugly but he won us some games

 

[whodizking]

Ill give it to Jay just becuz he had the determination to win, lke the Oakland game and two well he was the only stable QB we had since Marino. The rest were worst and hurt lol.

 

[Dolfan984]

Jay Fiedler was a ****ing savage

 

[LennyV]

I can't believe I am saying this... I Miss Jay

 

[shula_guy]

jay cutler........oh wait you meant the Jay who did play for us, nevermind

 

[Dr. Tomorrow]

Fiedler was all that was man

 

[bastid]

Fiedler anyday over Chad.. Fiedler was a baller and warrior.. Say what you want to about him but he came to play and showed heart. Something none of our QBs have done recently. I can't remember how many times I watched him about to get sacked and pulls a mcnabb move and gets away. And I cant remember how many times I watched him about to get sacked just to get away and fumble it to them. But I would still rather have Fiedler.. Atleast he was mobile and had a stronger arm than Chad :up:

 

[marinotoclayton]

I can't believe all of you would want Fieldler!!! I hated Jay. Yeah he might have had some heart. And i know it wasn't his fault he was starter for so many years. But my god you cringed every time he was going to throw the ball. At least Pennington so far has been pretty smart in his Qb play so far. So until Pennington starts making Fiedleresc moves. I will stick with Penny. Until he starts to give me that sour feeling. Which I already have because we are losing.

Now i would be open to seeing more of Henne or Beck. And no I am not totally in love with either of them . But I do want to see what the future holds after Penny since he is an obvious stopgap. And week 5 might be a great time to bring one in for a start.

 

[SCLSU Mud Dogs]

fiedler of the early 2000's definitely.

Present day choice? Penny.