john beck if cam was the coach?

[Rick Cartman]

just thought about this when i was board at work? knowing cam's slow qb growing process do you think if cam was still around beck would be slated to start?

 

[dlockz]

just thought about this when i was board at work? knowing cam's slow qb growing process do you think if cam was still around beck would be slated to start?

\
I think we resign lemon , keep Green or go out and trade a 4th for Jamie Martin. We then start Green once again and from there we just suck.

 

[C-HUCKS]

I would say if we kept cam, he would have resigned Green and he would have been the starter. The result would have been that we would have been lucky to win 3 games.

 

[THE STACHE]

If Cam was still coach we would still be flirting with making history 0-16!

 

[BobDole]

i think green was done here either way. and yes, i think beck would be slated to be the starter if cam was still here (destroying the franchise).

although i don't believe beck is the next big thing in miami, i still think he should be given a shot to start.

 

[THE STACHE]

Thanks Cam & Beck now Dave Wannestant & Jay Fielder are not considered the worst coach-QB combo in Dolphins History.

 

[Bumpus]

Who cares, Cam is gone.

 

[BobDole]

Thanks Cam & Beck now Dave Wannestant & Jay Fielder are not considered the worst coach-QB combo in Dolphins History.

we've had far worse QB's than fiedler w/wannstedt. almost too many to list. fiedler might even be the best qb wannstedt had, although that doesn't say too much.

 

[fatkirstyalley]

We would have traded for David Carr...since it was between green and carr last offseason. We would have resigned Samkon Gado and cut ricky....Lo book would have sat the first 10 games and we would have drafted Matt Ryan

 

[fatkirstyalley]

Oh and he would have made the Ted ginn family exclusively a Kick returner and signed Dante Hall to play reciever exclusively

 

[dlockz]

We would have traded for David Carr...since it was between green and carr last offseason. We would have resigned Samkon Gado and cut ricky....Lo book would have sat the first 10 games and we would have drafted Matt Ryan

No way Cam takes the best prospect at qb in the draft he would have drafted Desean jackson number one. Im mad that the Eagles got Ted Ginn in the second round this year lol.

 

[NewPhinPhan]

Thanks Cam & Beck now Dave Wannestant & Jay Fielder are not considered the worst coach-QB combo in Dolphins History.

It's a little early in Beck's career to be lumping him together with Cam. Sure, Cam drafted him, but if it wasn't Cam, it'd have been someone else, and Cam's name would have been associated with a different QB.

Like Cam/Edwards - and we wouldn't have seen how God-like Edwards has been with the Bills (TIC)

 

[RockyMtnPhinfan]

jesus Who Remembers The Ray Lucas Dabacle? aj Feely? Poop!!

 

[dlockz]

It's a little early in Beck's career to be lumping him together with Cam. Sure, Cam drafted him, but if it wasn't Cam, it'd have been someone else, and Cam's name would have been associated with a different QB.

Like Cam/Edwards - and we wouldn't have seen how God-like Edwards has been with the Bills (TIC)

People really hate on the Bills Qb looking better than ours lol. Edwards gets no props even though he had no prep to be the starter and had to come into the game versus the best team in football but of course no qb could possibly be better than Beck.

 

[NewPhinPhan]

Sorry you took that as hating. He had a pretty good season with the Bills. However, some people have made him look like some sort of God, while bashing Beck. My words were a play on that.

And I haven't bashed Edwards at all, although noone on here should really care, since he's not a Phin.

And, of course, I'VE never said there's no better QB than Beck.

Too reactionary today, D.