ckparrothead said:My disappointment with Eddie has never stemmed too much from the injuries. That lisfranc injury is real tough one to come back from, a career-ender. And last year I think he took an injury on the same wet slippery dirt infield that Ed Perry and a few others got injured on.
My disappointment in him stems from his play when he has been healthy. I know some of you guys have given him good reviews when he's on the field but he just never made the plays that a 2nd round pick linebacker should be making. I know there's plenty of excuses but sometimes I just feel like you can stuff your sorries in a sack as far as football production goes; you either produce or you don't. I mean if you think about Moore's draft standing, I know many will say we reached for him, but he was probably taken at a discount due to his injury history in college, so when he actually gets on the field the guy should be playing like a first round linebacker...it's just that he suffers third round injuries.
Look at a similar situation with Channing Crowder. We got Crowder in the 3rd round because he was a 1st round linebacker talent with a 5th round injury history. Knock on wood we haven't had to deal yet with his injury problems, but right now as he's on the field and playing injury-free we can clearly see the guy's first round ability. All I'm saying is that with Eddie Moore, I never saw that.
Nice anaylsis CK. I agree with you for the most part however I think that taking Moore in the 2nd round was WAY to early. From watching Moore closley in college and the pros, it seems that he takes to many steps getting to the acion, which was a much bigger problem in college. It also seems to me that he has too many tackes broken. Either way I think Moore could have still been there in the 4th or even 5th but we took him in the 2nd. As far as OLBs went that year I would have ranked him about 15th or so. There we some really good LBs availble before we took Moore including, Antwan Peek, Chaun Thompson, Pisa Tinomaosua (sp), Lance Briggs, and Robert Mathis. Either way I still dont think Moore has 1st round talent I would give him in the range of 3-5th round talent, dont see him starting here, but I am pulling for him either way.